In brief

  • The plea was dismissed as inadmissible, so the law remains unchanged. The Constitutional Court delivered Decision no. 316 on 1 April 2026, unanimously, and the text appeared in the Official Gazette of Romania (Monitorul Oficial), Part I, no. 879 of 20 October 2026, 202 days after it was delivered. The Public Ministry had asked the Court to find unconstitutional the restriction under which a revision based on a finding of unconstitutionality may be sought only in favour of the convicted person, and the Court never reached the substance of that complaint.
  • Revision on grounds of unconstitutionality remains open only in favour of the convicted person. Article 453(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure keeps the restriction, and Article 457(1) keeps the one-year time limit running from publication in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, of the decision upholding the plea. Neither the prosecutor nor the civil party may use this ground of revision against a person who has been convicted or acquitted by a final judgment.
  • A decision dismissing a plea opens no time limit for revision. Anyone counting one year from 20 October 2026 is counting wrongly: the time limit runs only from the publication of a decision upholding a plea, and only for the person who raised that plea in their own case. On top of that, revision may be sought only against final judgments that disposed of the substance of the case, not against a preliminary interlocutory judgment and not against the decision by which a court formally noted the withdrawal of an appeal.
Act: Decision of the Constitutional Court of Romania no. 316 of 1 April 2026 on the plea of unconstitutionality concerning Article 453(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, in the wording prior to Law no. 201/2023, and Article 457(1) with reference to Article 453(1)(f) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
Published: Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 879 of 20 October 2026, pages 2-6
Who it affects: people convicted by a final judgment who are considering an application for revision, the lawyers who draft such applications, prosecutors, the criminal courts and, in concrete terms, the Panel of 5 Judges of the High Court of Cassation and Justice, which has before it the two case files from which the plea originated
Takes effect: from 20 October 2026, the date of publication. The operative part states that the decision is final and generally binding and that it is given under Article 146(d) and Article 147(4) of the Constitution, the latter linking its effects to publication

The Constitutional Court has declined to answer one of the questions that have been put to it year after year in criminal matters: may a prosecutor ask for a case closed by a final judgment to be reopened, where a provision on which that judgment rested has been declared unconstitutional at the prosecutor’s own request? By Decision no. 316 of 1 April 2026, published on 20 October 2026, the plea was dismissed as inadmissible, with no examination of the substance. For the reader this means one practical thing: nothing changes in the Code of Criminal Procedure, and the rules in Article 453 and Article 457 apply exactly as they applied before.

Revision is an extraordinary remedy. It is neither an appeal nor an appeal in cassation: the trial is over, the judgment is final, and revision reopens it, in the cases strictly listed by law. The ground in Article 453(1)(f) differs from the others, because its basis is not a fact discovered after the trial but a decision of the Constitutional Court. The text requires two cumulative conditions: the judgment must have rested on the provision declared unconstitutional, and the consequences of the breach of the Constitution must continue to arise and be impossible to remove otherwise than through revision.

The plea was raised by the Public Ministry, the Prosecutor’s Office attached to the High Court of Cassation and Justice, Judicial Division, Criminal Judicial Service, in case files no. 2.687/1/2020/a1 and no. 2.689/1/2020/a1 of the High Court of Cassation and Justice, Panel of 5 Judges. At the Constitutional Court the two referrals became case files no. 384D/2021 and no. 650D/2021, joined at the sitting of 11 November 2025. The stake was concrete: the prosecution wanted to rely on Decision no. 547 of 7 July 2020, which had found unconstitutional certain powers of the Section for the Investigation of Offences within the Judiciary, among them the power to withdraw appeals. In the two cases, the appeal lodged by the National Anticorruption Directorate had been withdrawn by that very section, and the prosecution sought revision in order to undo the effect of the withdrawal. The obstacle: Article 453(3) states that this ground may be invoked only in favour of the convicted person or of the person in respect of whom the imposition of a penalty was waived or deferred. That is how the complaint of unconstitutionality arose.

The Court found two reasons for inadmissibility. The first is the absence of any link with the disposal of the case, required by Article 29(1) of Law no. 47/1992: the applications for revision had been directed against a preliminary interlocutory judgment and against a decision by which the appeal court had formally noted the withdrawal of the appeal, that is, against judgments which had not disposed of the substance of the criminal case. An application for revision framed in that way is inadmissible from the outset, and a plea raised in proceedings that were inadmissible from the start is itself inadmissible. The second reason concerns jurisdiction: under Article 2(3) of the same law, the Court rules only on constitutionality, while the interpretation and application of the law in the individual case remain with the courts of law, under Article 126 of the Constitution.

What it changes in practice

The decision is final and generally binding from 20 October 2026, the date of publication. Being a dismissal, it removes no rule from the legal order and adds none. Article 453(1)(f), Article 453(3) and Article 457(1) continue to apply, with the qualification that paragraph (3) has meanwhile been amended by Article I point 50 of Law no. 201/2023, and that the Court examined the wording in force before that law, namely the wording applicable when it was seised.

For people convicted by a final judgment, the route stays open on the same conditions: a decision of the Constitutional Court upholding a plea, delivered in their own case, consequences that continue to arise, and an application lodged within one year of the publication of that decision in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I. For prosecutors and for civil parties, the practical answer is still no: Article 453(3) does not give them this ground of revision, and the Court left the restriction untouched.

For the two case files before the High Court of Cassation and Justice, the effect is this: the Panel of 5 Judges continues its examination of admissibility in principle without an answer from the Constitutional Court on the question raised. And for anyone calculating time limits, the decision is a warning: 20 October 2026 is not the starting point of any time limit, because the one-year period in Article 457(1) is tied to the publication of a decision upholding a plea, not to the publication of any decision of the Court.

What has changed compared with the previous situation

In the letter of the law, nothing. In the way the law is read, something does change: the Court expressly cuts off an argument used for several years in applications for revision, namely that Decision no. 2 of 17 January 2017 would apply by analogy to the ground in letter (f) as well. The 2017 decision concerned the ground in letter (a), the discovery of new facts or circumstances, and led to the removal of a restriction that excluded the revision of an acquittal. The Court now shows that the two grounds are configured differently: letter (a) puts the reconstruction of the facts back in issue, whereas letter (f) does not concern the dynamics of judicial truth but alignment with a ruling on constitutionality, with due regard for legal certainty and for the prospective effects of the Court’s decisions.

The decision takes its place in a line of case law that practitioners need to keep in mind. Decision no. 126 of 3 March 2016 confined the ground in letter (f) to the case in which the plea was raised, hence to the person who raised it, not to anyone holding a judgment based on that rule. Decision no. 651 of 25 October 2018 split decisions upholding pleas into two groups: those leading to decriminalisation or to a reduction of the maximum penalty fall under Article 4 of the Criminal Code and Article 595 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, while the rest are given effect through revision under letter (f), only in favour of the convicted person. Decision no. 316/2026 confirms that division and restates it in its reasons, without disturbing it.

Advantages and disadvantages

What it improves

  • It confirms, in its reasons, that revision based on a decision of the Constitutional Court remains a remedy available only in favour of the convicted person, which closes a debate carried on in practice ever since Decision no. 547 of 7 July 2020.
  • It restates the boundary of what may be revised: only final judgments that disposed of the substance of the criminal case, not preliminary interlocutory judgments and not judgments by which a court formally notes the withdrawal of an appeal.
  • It gives legal certainty to people acquitted or convicted by a final judgment, who run no risk of having their trial reopened to their detriment on the basis of a finding that a procedural rule is unconstitutional.
  • It explains why the ground in letter (f) cannot be treated by analogy with the one in letter (a), which shortens the argument in future applications and in the courts’ replies.
  • It states clearly the separation of powers: applying the law in the individual case remains with the courts, under Article 126 of the Constitution, not with the constitutional court.
  • It was delivered unanimously, so there are no dissenting opinions leaving room for a competing reading of the outcome.

What remains a problem

  • The substantive question remains unanswered: whether the restriction in Article 453(3) is constitutional where the plea was raised by the prosecutor himself, nobody has said, not even in 2026.
  • Between delivery, on 1 April 2026, and publication, on 20 October 2026, 202 days passed, and throughout that period the decision could not be invoked by anyone, because its effects are tied to publication.
  • From the first referral, the interlocutory judgment of 10 December 2020, to publication, 2,140 days passed, almost 5 years and 10 months, for an outcome that does not touch the substance.
  • The text examined is no longer in force in the version considered: Article 453(3) had been amended by Law no. 201/2023, published on 6 July 2023, 2 years and almost 9 months before the decision was delivered.
  • Delivery was postponed four times, to 10 December 2025, 22 January 2026, 4 March 2026 and 1 April 2026, the last time because not all the judges who had taken part in the hearing were present.
  • Paragraph 14 announces that the absence of a link with the case is a decisive bar preventing any further examination, yet 16 more paragraphs of examination follow, and paragraph 34 even signals a possible dismissal on the substance. The reader cannot tell which of these reasons is binding.
  • The decision says nothing about the fate of the applications for revision already dismissed on the same reasoning over the past five years, although the reasons would have been useful to the courts.

Practical advice

  1. Check first whether the decision upholding a plea that you rely on was delivered in your own case. After Decision no. 126 of 3 March 2016, the ground in letter (f) is confined to the case in which the plea was raised, so a decision obtained by someone else does not open the route for you.
  2. Count the one-year period from the date of publication in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, of the decision upholding the plea, not from the date it was delivered. The gap between the two dates can run to months, as this very file shows.
  3. Do not count any time limit from Decision no. 316/2026. It is a decision dismissing a plea, and Article 457(1) ties the time limit to a decision that found a provision unconstitutional.
  4. Look closely at the judgment you are challenging. If it is a preliminary interlocutory judgment, or a judgment by which the court formally noted the withdrawal of an appeal, the application is inadmissible from the outset, however solid the rest of the argument may be.
  5. If the decision upholding the plea concerns a rule defining an offence and leads to decriminalisation or to a lower maximum penalty, the route to take is Article 595 of the Code of Criminal Procedure together with Article 4 of the Criminal Code, not revision, as held in Decision no. 651 of 25 October 2018.
  6. Prove both conditions in letter (f) in your application, not just the first: that the judgment rested on the rule declared unconstitutional, and that the consequences continue to arise and cannot be removed otherwise.
  7. If you are a prosecutor or a civil party seeking a change to someone’s detriment, look for another ground in Article 453(1). The ground in letter (f) stays closed to that direction.
  8. Check the wording of the applicable text as it stood at the moment that interests you. Article 453(3) has a version before and a version after Law no. 201/2023, and the decision discusses the earlier one.

Frequently asked questions

What exactly did the Constitutional Court decide?
It dismissed as inadmissible the plea concerning Article 453(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, in the wording prior to Law no. 201/2023, and Article 457(1), read in relation to the ground of revision in Article 453(1)(f). The dismissal is for inadmissibility, not on the substance, so the complaint was never weighed.
Does anything change in the Code of Criminal Procedure?
No. A decision dismissing a plea leaves the texts exactly as they were. The only change is in how those texts will be read, because the Court explains in its reasons why the ground in letter (f) cannot be treated in the same way as the one in letter (a).
What is revision, in a few words?
An extraordinary remedy that reopens a criminal trial already closed by a final judgment, only on the grounds listed in Article 453(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. It is not a third trial available to anyone dissatisfied with the judgment.
Why is the ground in letter (f) different from the others?
Because its basis is a decision of the Constitutional Court, not a new fact discovered after the trial. The other grounds put the facts back in issue, whereas letter (f) calls for the judgment to be aligned with a ruling on the constitutionality of the rule applied.
Can I seek revision on the basis of Decision no. 316/2026?
No. No provision was declared unconstitutional by it, so there is no basis for the ground in letter (f) and no one-year period starts running from 20 October 2026.
How long do I have for an application on the ground in letter (f)?
One year from the date of publication in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, of the decision upholding the plea of unconstitutionality. This is an exception to the rule in Article 457(1), under which an application in favour of the convicted person may be made at any time.
Can the prosecutor seek revision to my detriment on this ground?
No, not on the ground in letter (f). Article 453(3) reserves it to the convicted person and to the person in respect of whom the imposition of a penalty was waived or deferred, and that restriction remains in force.
Which judgments can be revised?
Only final judgments that disposed of the substance of the criminal case. The decision shows that a preliminary interlocutory judgment, and a judgment by which the court formally noted the withdrawal of an appeal, do not fall into that category.
Why did so much time pass between delivery and publication?
The decision does not explain the 202 days between 1 April 2026 and 20 October 2026. The law sets the Court no time limit for publication, and the effects of a decision arise only once it is published.
What happens to the two case files before the High Court?
The Panel of 5 Judges continues its examination of the admissibility in principle of the applications for revision, with the texts unchanged. The decision is communicated to it, as noted at the end of the text, but it gives no answer on the question raised by the prosecution.

Errors and inconsistencies in the published text

  • Paragraph 35, the closing parenthesis. The text states that a revision to the detriment of an acquitted person was possible „în cazul Deciziei nr. 547 din 7 iulie 2020, invocată ad similis în prezenta cauză”, that is, in the case of that decision, relied on by analogy in these proceedings. The statement contradicts Article 453(3), quoted in paragraph 11, and the Court’s own conclusion in paragraph 32, according to which such a decision may be given effect only in favour of the convicted person. Had it been possible, the plea raised by the prosecution would have had no object. The text does not allow the reader to establish whether this refers to a line of case law, to a hypothesis or to a drafting error, and a prosecutor and a defence lawyer may reach opposite conclusions reading the same sentence.
  • Paragraph 14 against paragraphs 23 to 38, with paragraph 34. Paragraph 14 treats the absence of a link with the disposal of the case as a decisive bar, with peremptory effect on the examination of the other conditions of admissibility „indiferent de natura acestora”, whatever their nature, and on the examination of the substance. Yet 16 paragraphs follow which carry out exactly that examination, and paragraph 34 states that the specific features of the ground in letter (f) „ar putea justifica o respingere pe fond a excepției”, could justify dismissing the plea on the substance. Whether the reasons in paragraphs 25 to 38 are binding cannot be established from the act: either the first ground blocked the examination, or it did not.
  • Paragraph 25. The sentence states that the two grounds of revision are configured differently „întrucât temeiul revizuirii în acest din urmă caz îl constituie o decizie a Curții Constituționale de admitere a unei excepții de neconstituționalitate”, because the basis of revision in the latter case is a decision of the Constitutional Court upholding a plea of unconstitutionality, after mentioning letter (f) and then letter (a) in that order. The reference therefore falls on letter (a), the ground of new facts or circumstances, even though a decision of the Constitutional Court is the basis of the ground in letter (f), as the text quoted in paragraph 11 and the reasoning in paragraph 33 both show. The distinction on which the whole reasoning rests appears inverted in the very sentence that states it.

Editorial analysis

The most telling figure in this file is not written in it. The revision the Public Ministry wanted to obtain rested on Decision no. 547 of 7 July 2020, published on 19 August 2020. For any new application based on that decision, the one-year period in Article 457(1) closed on 19 August 2021, which is 1,888 days before Decision no. 316/2026 reached the Official Gazette of Romania. Even had the plea been upheld, the window for new applications had long since shut; the outcome would have served only those who had lodged their applications in 2020, among them the parties in the two case files before the High Court. A constitutional review that reaches its addressee after the expiry of the very time limit it discusses loses part of its purpose.

The ratio between the time limits imposed on the two sides says the rest. The citizen is given one year, counted from a publication he does not control, to lodge an application for revision. The Court is given no time limit at all: 202 days from delivery, on 1 April 2026, to publication, on 20 October 2026, and 2,140 days from the first referring interlocutory judgment, of 10 December 2020. Between the hearing of 11 November 2025 and delivery, another 141 days and four postponements went by, the last because not all the judges who had taken part in the hearing were still present. None of this is unlawful, but a limitation period that runs from a date set by the institution that has no time limit of its own is not a balance, it is an asymmetry.

On the merits, the decision is right on inadmissibility: an application for revision directed against a preliminary interlocutory judgment could not succeed, and a plea raised in proceedings that are inadmissible has no link with their disposal. The problem is what the Court does after finding this. It declares the bar decisive in paragraph 14, then builds 16 paragraphs of reasoning on the substance, with a clear conclusion in paragraph 32 and a signal of dismissal on the substance in paragraph 34. The result is a text from which a practitioner can extract the rule he needs but cannot say whether it binds him. Beyond that, the Court discusses a text that Law no. 201/2023 had already amended, on 6 July 2023, so the outcome concerns a wording that has fallen out of use, without saying whether the reasoning carries over to the version in force. A smaller mismatch is added in paragraph 23, where Decision no. 2 of 17 January 2017 appears first as concerning Article 453(4), first sentence, and two sentences later as concerning Article 457(2).

What should be changed

  • A statutory time limit for publishing the decisions of the Constitutional Court, 30 days from delivery for example. The 202-day gap in this file would not recur, and the one-year period in Article 457(1) would become predictable for the person who has to calculate it.
  • Communication of the decision to the parties in the case in which the plea was raised, with the time limit running from that communication. The person entitled to seek revision would no longer depend on reading the Official Gazette of Romania every day in order not to lose a right.
  • The legislature should settle expressly whether the Public Ministry may seek revision on the ground in letter (f) where it raised the plea itself. The question has been pending since 2020 and has consumed two case files and almost six years without an answer; an amendment to Article 453(3) would close the debate one way or the other.
  • The Court should mark expressly what is obiter dictum when it continues its reasoning after a decisive bar. A single sentence at the start of paragraph 23 would spare the courts and the legal profession the uncertainty about the binding force of paragraphs 25 to 38.
  • Article 453(1) should state in its text that revision concerns only judgments that disposed of the substance of the case. Applications directed against interlocutory judgments would no longer reach the stage of admissibility in principle, where they consume hearing dates and, at times, years of proceedings.
  • The operative part of decisions delivered on texts amended in the meantime should state whether the outcome applies to the version in force as well. The reader would no longer have to infer from paragraph 10 that the wording adjudicated upon is one that Law no. 201/2023 has replaced.

Original text of the legal act

The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.

The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania

Official Gazette of Romania no. 879 of 20 October 2026, pages 2-6 8 pages PDF, 83 KB the act starts on page 2

Open the official PDFDownload the PDF

The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.