In brief

  • Local authorities will be able to pay for individual gas boilers out of their own budgets for two more years, in buildings connected to district heating substations that serve fewer than 50 final users. The Constitutional Court rejected, by a majority of votes, the objection raised by the President of Romania and found that the law approving Government Ordinance no. 16/2025 is constitutional in relation to the criticisms raised. Paragraph 54 closes the discussion: Parliament exercised, within constitutional limits, its exclusive power to choose the form and the methods of transposing the directive, including by setting a two-year period for specific situations.
  • The European prohibition that the exception sidesteps has a fixed date, 1 January 2025. Article 17(15) of Directive (EU) 2024/1275 provides that, from that date at the latest, Member States no longer provide financial incentives for the installation of stand-alone boilers powered by fossil fuels. The Court read the directive through Article 288 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union: what binds the State is the result, while the form and the means remain its own choice. Paragraph 51 holds that the exception, being temporary and specific, runs counter neither to the provisions of the directive nor to its objective, under which existing buildings should be transformed into zero-emission buildings by 2050.
  • One judge wrote a dissenting opinion, and the Government itself asked for the law to be struck down. Judge Dacian-Cosmin Dragoș argues that the margin of appreciation under Article 288 TFEU concerns the form and the means of transposition, not the objective that has to be achieved, and that the two-year exception falls within none of those the directive allows. The Government took the same position, finding in its own submission that the objection was well founded, and so asking the Court to strike down the law approving its own ordinance. The President of the Chamber of Deputies defended the text, while the President of the Senate submitted no position at all.
Act: Decision of the Constitutional Court of Romania no. 837 of 15 July 2026 on the objection of unconstitutionality concerning the Law approving Government Ordinance no. 16/2025 for the transposition of Article 17(15) of Directive (EU) 2024/1275 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 24 April 2024 on the energy performance of buildings and for the amendment and supplementation of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 18/2009 on improving the energy performance of residential blocks
Published: Official Gazette of Romania (Monitorul Oficial), Part I, no. 890 of 23 October 2026, pages 2-10
Delivered: 15 July 2026, by a majority of votes, in a panel of nine judges, with one dissenting opinion
Final and generally binding: 23 October 2026, the date of publication

Public money for fossil fuel boilers does not stop at the European deadline. By Decision no. 837 of 15 July 2026, published on 23 October 2026, the Constitutional Court established that Parliament was entitled to add to the law approving Government Ordinance no. 16/2025 a two-year exception to the very prohibition that ordinance had taken over from European law. Four days earlier, on 19 October 2026, the Government had moved 2.67 million euro from the National Recovery and Resilience Plan to the heating decarbonisation reform, so the two flows of public money now run in parallel: one takes fossil fuels out of heating systems, the other pays for installing them where district heating has too few customers.

The text that reached the Court is short. The Chamber of Deputies approved the ordinance with a single addition, a new paragraph under Article III: „By way of exception to Article I, local public administration authorities out of their own funds, or central public authorities and institutions out of European funds, may grant financial incentives for the installation of stand-alone boilers powered by fossil fuels or of other individual heating systems, in the case of buildings or groups of buildings connected to district heating substations serving fewer than 50 final users, for a period of no more than 2 years from the entry into force of the law approving this ordinance.” Two figures, a threshold and a duration, is all the exception contains.

The paragraph came in as an amendment in the decision-making Chamber. Paragraph 45 of the decision reproduces the reasons given in the joint report of the Committee for Public Administration and Spatial Planning, the Committee for Industries and Services and the Committee for the Environment and Ecological Balance: underused substations carry fixed operating, maintenance and staff costs that cannot be covered from the tariffs charged to a small number of beneficiaries, and without a lawful alternative local councils would have to keep them running at a loss. The amendment, the committees say, „does not encourage the use of fossil fuels as a general solution”, but offers „a temporary and specific instrument”.

The timeline shows how tight the control was. The law was adopted under the urgency procedure on 1 April 2026 and sent for promulgation on 9 April 2026. The President of Romania referred the matter to the Court on 27 April 2026, on the eighteenth day of the 20-day promulgation period laid down in the second sentence of Article 77(1) of the Constitution, two days before it expired. The objection was registered under no. 6.964 and became Case file no. 2.785A/2026. 79 days passed between the referral and the ruling, and another 100 between the ruling and publication, so the law sat blocked at promulgation for 205 days from its adoption.

The President’s criticisms concerned Article 1(5), Article 147(4) and Article 148(2) and (4) of the Constitution, read together with Article 35 on the right to a healthy environment and Article 135(2)(e) on the State’s duty to restore and protect the environment. The substantive argument: a general exception to a rule laid down at European level amounts to suspending the effects of the directive in Romanian law. The referral also recalls that the delay in transposition led the European Commission to open Case COM 2025/0168 against Romania, and it describes the addition as an „impermissible legislative regression”, because it lowers a level of protection already attained.

The defence came from the President of the Chamber of Deputies, who pointed out that the rule is permissive, optional and temporary, so it obliges nobody to buy a gas boiler, and that the directive itself requires Member States to provide „adequate funding, support measures and other instruments capable of removing market barriers”. The Government, by contrast, found the objection well founded and relied on its own explanatory memorandum to the ordinance, together with Commission Communication C/2024/6206 on the phasing out of financial incentives for stand-alone boilers powered by fossil fuels, published in the Official Journal of the European Union, C series, of 18 October 2024. The President of the Senate sent nothing.

The Court first examined admissibility against the three conditions in the first sentence of Article 146(a) of the Constitution and Article 15(2) of Law no. 47/1992: who may refer the matter, the time limit and the object of the review. All three were met. It then turned to the test it set for itself in 2011, in Decision no. 668 of 18 May 2011 and Decision no. 921 of 7 July 2011: a rule of European law may be used as an interposed norm in the constitutionality review only if it is sufficiently clear, precise and unambiguous and, on top of that, has constitutional relevance. Paragraphs 49 and 50 find both conditions satisfied, so Article 17(15) of the directive could indeed be used as a benchmark.

The outcome was dismissal all the same. Paragraph 51 holds that an exception „of a temporary and specific nature” does not run counter to the provisions or the objective of the directive. Paragraph 52 brings in Article 288 TFEU, under which a directive „shall be binding, as to the result to be achieved, upon each Member State to which it is addressed, but shall leave to the national authorities the choice of form and methods”. Paragraph 54 classifies the two-year window as an „implementation deadline” set for specific situations, while paragraph 57 calls it a „suspensive term for the performance of an obligation of the State” and concludes that the law „transposes the directive and guarantees its full and effective application”. On the right to a healthy environment, paragraph 56 finds that a measure limited in time and applicable only to small substations does not encourage fossil fuels as a general solution. The criticism based on the binding force of the Court’s own decisions fell in a single sentence, paragraph 58: the case law relied on was not applicable.

The dissenting opinion of Judge Dacian-Cosmin Dragoș attacks the central piece of the reasoning. The margin of appreciation under Article 288 TFEU concerns the form and the means of transposition, „and not the objective that has to be achieved”, he writes, and the exception introduced by the law resembles none of those the directive permits: maintenance, repair or decommissioning of existing boilers, hybrid systems with a significant share of renewable energy, the transition to gas from renewable sources, support for the price of energy unconnected with the installation of a boiler, State aid, and programmes adopted before 1 January 2025. The two-year window, as he reads it, breaches the purpose of the directive and the State’s positive obligation to mitigate potentially irreversible effects of climate change, an obligation for which he invokes the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of 9 April 2024 in Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland.

What it changes in practice

The decision is final and generally binding from 23 October 2026, the date of publication. For the law, the immediate consequence is that the road to promulgation has been unblocked: under Article 77(3) of the Constitution, where a review of constitutionality has been requested, promulgation takes place within no more than 10 days of receipt of the decision confirming that the law is constitutional. The decision is communicated to the President of Romania, so the law should be promulgated and published in the Official Gazette of Romania in the first days of November 2026, and as a law it will enter into force 3 days after publication, under Article 12(1) of Law no. 24/2000.

The window of up to two years starts running from that moment. Who may pay: local public administration authorities, out of their own funds, and central public authorities and institutions, out of European funds. What may be paid for: the installation of stand-alone boilers powered by fossil fuels or of other individual heating systems. Where: in buildings or groups of buildings connected to district heating substations serving fewer than 50 final users. Outside this perimeter, the prohibition in Article I of Government Ordinance no. 16/2025 remains intact, and the older exceptions in Article III(1) and (2) and in Article VIII continue to apply alongside it.

For a flat owner, nothing changes about buying with their own money. The prohibition has from the start concerned financial incentives from public funds, not the purchase of a boiler out of pocket or on a bank loan. What changes is access to public money for people living in buildings served by small substations, and here the decision creates no right at all: the paragraph says „may grant”, so each local council decides whether to open such support and with what budget.

At European level, the decision closes nothing. The infringement procedure in Case COM 2025/0168 was opened by the European Commission and will be heard, if need be, before the Court of Justice of the European Union, the only court whose interpretation of the directive is binding. A ruling of the national constitutional court neither binds nor halts it, so the financial risk invoked in the President’s referral remains on the table. Romania now also has a law whose compatibility with Article 17(15) was confirmed in Bucharest and contested by its own Government before the Court.

The second effect, harder to see, is that of the grounds. Article 147(4) of the Constitution makes them generally binding, and paragraphs 52 and 54 put in writing a generous reading of the margin of appreciation: the State may set its own implementation deadlines for „specific situations” without breaching the directive. That formula can be invoked in any other dispute about transposing a directive, not only in the one about boilers, and it is the part of the decision that will be cited most often.

What has changed compared with the previous situation

Until the approving law, the national rule was simple. Government Ordinance no. 16/2025, adopted on 21 August 2025 and published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 787 of 22 August 2025, prohibits in Article I the granting of financial incentives from public funds for the installation of stand-alone boilers powered by fossil fuels. The prohibition applies from the entry into force of the ordinance, from 25 August 2025, 3 days after publication.

Exceptions existed before as well, but they were of a different nature. Article III(1) takes out of the prohibition the maintenance, repair and decommissioning of boilers, building automation, the installation of natural gas boilers where the local network already carries gas from renewable sources, systems combined with renewable energy, works for the transition to renewable gas, support for the price of energy unconnected with the installation of a boiler, and incentives communicated to final beneficiaries before the ordinance entered into force. Paragraph (2) adds State aid for undertakings, and Article VIII takes out investments financed from the National Recovery and Resilience Plan, from the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development and, under strict conditions, from the European Regional Development Fund and the Cohesion Fund, if the programmes were adopted before 1 January 2025.

The substantive difference brought by the new paragraph is the criterion. All the older exceptions turn either on the nature of the expenditure or on the date when the funding programme was adopted. The new one turns on the size of the substation: under 50 final users is allowed, 50 and above is not. It is the first exception in this act that depends on a number of people rather than on the type of work or on a calendar, and the only one whose justification comes from losses in local budgets rather than from the text of the directive.

Those losses include a debt. The price difference on heat supplied to households, which town halls owe district heating companies, is among the payment arrears covered by the 2 billion lei of VAT revenue shared out to local budgets in November 2026.

For fuel for the 2026-2027 winter, local authorities with district heating have also been given access to State Treasury loans of up to 75 million lei per city, under Emergency Ordinance no. 43/2026.

The legal status of the law has changed too. Between 1 April and 23 October 2026, local councils hoping for the two-year window had nothing to rely on, because the law had not been promulgated. Nor could the outcome be predicted: the Government and the President were asking for the same thing, and the only authority that defended the text before the Court was the Chamber that had voted it.

Advantages and disadvantages

What it improves

  • Local councils with almost empty substations get out of the trap described in paragraphs 21 and 45: the fixed costs of operation, maintenance and staff cannot be covered from the bills of a few dozen users, and until now there was no legal basis for the alternative.
  • For the residents of these buildings, the service can be replaced with one that works, instead of formally keeping alive a substation that delivers hot water intermittently and loses heat along the pipes.
  • The rule is permissive, not mandatory. No authority is obliged to grant incentives and no owners’ association is obliged to disconnect, and that distinction is the very argument on which the Court’s solution rests.
  • The law comes out of uncertainty. After 205 days from adoption, local councils and ministries finally know whether they can build a programme on the two-year window.
  • The grounds confirm a national margin of appreciation in transposition, useful in other files where Romania faces tight European deadlines and local realities that do not fit them.

What remains a problem

  • The threshold of 50 final users is defined nowhere. In district heating, „user” usually means the owners’ association rather than the flat, and the difference between the two readings moves a whole block from one side of the threshold to the other.
  • The European funds branch clashes with Article VIII of the same ordinance, which lets European money through only on two cumulative conditions. The new paragraph requires neither, so a managing authority that relies on it risks ineligible expenditure, and that comes back on the public budget.
  • The decision does nothing to reduce the risk in Case COM 2025/0168. The European Commission is not bound by a ruling of the national constitutional court, and the binding interpretation of the directive belongs to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
  • The monitoring obligation that the ordinance places on the authorities granting incentives, recalled in paragraph 4, has not been extended to the new exception, so boilers paid for by this route fall outside the act’s only control mechanism.
  • A boiler installed in 2027 has a service life running past 2050, the year by which existing buildings should be zero-emission. Whoever pays for the installation now will also pay, within that span, for the replacement.
  • The wording also covers „other individual heating systems”, which the directive never prohibited. Part of the exception therefore derogates from a prohibition that does not exist.

Practical advice

  1. If you live in a block connected to district heating and are interested in the support, ask the local council or the operator in writing how many final users the substation you depend on serves. Fewer than 50 is the only way in, and a written answer will also serve you later, in the file.
  2. Do not count flats. The law speaks of final users, and in heat supply contracts the user is usually the owners’ association. Ask which definition applies in the local council decision that opens the support.
  3. Check the deadline in calendar dates, not in years. The window runs from the entry into force of the approving law, not from the date you file your application, so anyone moving in the second year has less time than anyone moving now.
  4. For central authorities: before launching a call for European funding on the basis of the new paragraph, set it against Article VIII of Government Ordinance no. 16/2025 and against the rules of the funding programme. A paragraph in national law does not make eligible an expenditure that the European rules reject.
  5. For associations comparing options, ask for the cost over 20 years, not for the year of installation: installation, servicing, fuel and replacement. The decision does not change the 2050 target and promises nobody that the support will be repeated after the two years.
  6. If the legal reasoning is what interests you, go straight to paragraphs 47 to 57 and to the dissenting opinion. Paragraph 54 contains the reasoning on which the solution rests, and the dissenting opinion is the only place in the act where the opposing argument is written out in full.

Frequently asked questions

What exactly did the Constitutional Court decide?
It dismissed the objection as unfounded and found that the law approving Government Ordinance no. 16/2025 is constitutional in relation to the criticisms raised. The final wording matters: the confirmation is given only in relation to the grounds invoked by the President of Romania, not for the law as a whole. The solution was reached by a majority of votes, in a panel of nine judges, with one dissenting opinion.
Has the law already entered into force?
No. On the date the decision was published, the law was still unpromulgated. Under Article 77(3) of the Constitution, promulgation takes place within no more than 10 days of receipt of the decision confirming constitutionality, and the law enters into force 3 days after its publication in the Official Gazette of Romania. Until then, the prohibition in Article I of the ordinance applies without the two-year exception.
Can I still install a gas boiler with my own money?
Yes, and it was never prohibited. The ordinance prohibits financial incentives from public funds for the installation, money from the State or the local council, not a purchase made out of pocket, on credit or from the association’s repair fund. What was and remains regulated separately are the technical approvals, disconnection from the district system and the safety conditions.
What does „fewer than 50 final users” mean?
The act does not say, and this is the exception’s biggest practical uncertainty. Neither the law nor the decision defines the final user or shows who does the counting. In heat supply contracts the user is usually the owners’ association, so a substation with 40 associations is above the threshold, while one with 10 associations and 400 flats is below it. Until there is a clarification, the answer comes from the local council decision that opens the support.
Does the decision get Romania out of the infringement procedure?
No. Case COM 2025/0168 was opened by the European Commission for the delay in transposition and is decided on Union law, not on the Romanian Constitution. The Commission is not bound by the ruling of the national constitutional court, and the binding interpretation of Article 17(15) of the directive belongs to the Court of Justice of the European Union. If it comes to that, the argument in the dissenting opinion is exactly the one the Commission will use.
Why did the Government ask for the striking down of the law approving its own ordinance?
Because the ordinance and the addition have different authors. The Government adopted Government Ordinance no. 16/2025 in order to transpose the European prohibition, and the new paragraph was introduced by amendment in the Chamber of Deputies, without its agreement. In the position it sent to the Court, the Government found the objection well founded and relied on its own explanatory memorandum, together with Commission Communication C/2024/6206 of 18 October 2024.
What happens after the two years?
The window closes by itself, with no need for a new act, and the prohibition in Article I becomes whole again for all cases. The act promises no extension and obliges nobody to provide funding after that deadline. Whoever installs a boiler within the window is left with it and with its running costs, including the replacement required by the zero-emission buildings target for 2050.
Does the dissenting opinion change anything in practice?
It produces no legal effects: what binds are the operative part and the grounds of the majority. Its value is of another kind. It shows that the solution passed by a majority and not unanimously, and it puts in writing, in the shortest form, the argument on which any future challenge will rest: the margin under Article 288 TFEU concerns the form and the means, not the objective.

Errors and inconsistencies in the published text

  • Paragraph 56 and the dissenting opinion refer to Article 34 of the Constitution for the right to a healthy environment. Paragraph 56 ends the analysis of the environmental criticism with the formula „consacrate de art. 34 și art. 135 alin. (2) lit. e) din Constituție”, and the dissenting opinion repeats the same reference. Article 34 of the Constitution governs the right to the protection of health; the right to a healthy environment is in Article 35, as correctly stated in paragraphs 32, 50 and 55 and throughout the reasoning of the objection. This is not a loss in text conversion: both occurrences read that way in the printed edition, pages 9 and 10 of the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 890. The consequence is that the only paragraph in which the Court closes the environmental criticism, a paragraph covered by the binding force of the grounds under Article 147(4) of the Constitution, points to a constitutional text other than the one it analysed.
  • Paragraph 8 sets the entry into force of Government Ordinance no. 16/2025 at 21 August 2025, one day before it was published. The text states that the ordinance „preia interdicția din directiva europeană de la momentul intrării sale în vigoare, respectiv 21 august 2025”, while paragraphs 31 and 38 show that the act was published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 787 of 22 August 2025. Under Article 12(1) of Law no. 24/2000, ordinances issued on the basis of an enabling law enter into force 3 days after publication unless they provide for a later date, so the real date is 25 August 2025, and an entry into force preceding publication is impossible. The date is not decorative: Article III(1)(g) of the ordinance takes out of the prohibition the incentives communicated to final beneficiaries „înainte de data intrării în vigoare a prezentei ordonanțe”, before the date on which the ordinance enters into force, so an incentive communicated on 22, 23 or 24 August 2025 falls within the exception under the correct date and outside it under the date printed in the decision. The error appears in the account of the reasons for the objection, not in the Court’s own grounds, but it remains the only date of entry into force of the ordinance that the act offers the reader.

Editorial analysis

The problem the exception starts from is real, and any mayor of a small town knows it: a substation designed for a few hundred flats, left with twenty, loses heat in empty pipes and pays operating wages that no bill can cover. There, an organised disconnection, with support for replacing the heat source, is cheaper for everyone than keeping the system alive. The argument convinced the Court and would have convinced anyone.

Except that the whole case rests on an unmeasured claim. The 59 paragraphs of the decision, the positions of the two authorities and the joint report of three parliamentary committees contain, between them, no figure other than the threshold of 50 and the duration of 2 years: no number of substations below the threshold, no quantified annual loss, no estimate of how many boilers would be subsidised and with what money. An exception to a European prohibition passed the constitutionality test with „significant financial losses” as its only evidence. By comparison, the President’s objection comes with one verifiable element, the number of the infringement case, and the Government with a second, Commission Communication C/2024/6206.

The second observation comes out of the calendar rather than the text. The directive required compliance by 1 January 2025. The ordinance transposing the prohibition was published on 22 August 2025, 233 days after the deadline, a delay for which the European Commission has already opened proceedings. On top of that delay, the law adds another two years, and they run from its own entry into force, a moment that is only now approaching, in November 2026. If the law is promulgated within the 10-day period and enters into force at the beginning of November 2026, the window closes in November 2028, that is 1,400 days, almost 46 months, after the date on which the European prohibition had become binding. The State’s delays are, taken together, longer than the derogation the State granted itself.

The third observation is not visible when reading the act from start to finish, because it appears only when the new paragraph is placed next to Article VIII of the ordinance it supplements. Article VIII lets European money finance fossil fuel boilers on two cumulative conditions alone: the funding programme must have been adopted before 1 January 2025, and the expenditure must be eligible under Article 7(1)(h)(i) of Regulation (EU) 2021/1058 or Article 73 of Regulation (EU) 2021/2115. The new paragraph allows central authorities to grant the same incentives „out of European funds”, with no condition at all. The same act now contains two gates for European money, of different widths, and the one opened by Parliament is wider than the regulations governing that money allow. The Court cites Article VIII in paragraph 42, as proof that the older exceptions fit within the directive, but it never sets the new exception against it. The practical risk is not theoretical: expenditure declared ineligible comes back on the budget that paid it.

There is also a problem in how the reasoning is built. Paragraphs 54 and 57 call the window an „implementation deadline” and a „suspensive term for the performance of an obligation of the State”. A suspensive term postpones an obligation that has not yet fallen due, and the obligation under Article 17(15) of the directive had been due since 1 January 2025, 15 months before the law was adopted. The law therefore postpones no deadline; it derogates once that deadline has passed. The judge who wrote the dissenting opinion reaches the same conclusion by another route, through the distinction between form and objective, but nobody in the act discusses the order of the dates. Also left undiscussed is the fact that the exception covers „other individual heating systems”, a category the directive never touched: a heat pump never needed Parliament’s permission, and including it makes the derogation look wider than it is. Finally, the dissenting opinion identifies the new text as „art. III1”, as an article, whereas the law introduces a paragraph, Article III(11); the confusion does not change the solution, but it sends the reader to a different place in the ordinance.

What should be changed

  • Correcting the reference to Article 34 of the Constitution, in paragraph 56 and in the dissenting opinion. This is done by a rectification in the Official Gazette of Romania, the usual procedure for material errors. The practical effect: the paragraph that closes the environmental criticism, the only one entering binding case law on this point, would cite the text that actually guarantees the right analysed, and a court invoking it would no longer have to correct the reference silently.
  • Making the European funds branch conditional on the cumulative conditions in Article VIII. The simplest option is to remove that branch from the paragraph, leaving the exception on the local authorities’ own funds. In practice, a managing authority launching a call would no longer risk a correction for ineligible expenditure, and the local budget would no longer be exposed to repayment after the money has been handed to beneficiaries.
  • Defining the final user and publishing the list of substations that fall below the threshold. The definition can be taken from the legislation on the public district heating service, and the list can be requested from the operators and the local authorities. The practical effect: the threshold would no longer depend on who does the counting, and an association could check, before spending money on design work, whether or not it falls within the scope of the exception.
  • Tying the window to a calendar date rather than to the entry into force of the law. The duration would then be fixed, instead of stretching with every day of procedural delay. In this file, the 205 days between adoption and publication of the decision pushed the final deadline back by nearly seven months, without anyone having decided so.
  • A reporting obligation when the window closes: how many incentives were granted, for how many substations and in what amount. The consequence: after two years there would be a figure for the file at the European Commission and for any extension, instead of the same qualitative claim on which the exception was built.
  • Extending the ordinance’s monitoring obligation to the new exception. The authority granting the incentive would track continued compliance with the minimum requirements, as it does for the other exceptions. In practice, boilers paid for from public money in this window would stay within the same control mechanism as the rest, and at the end of the two years it would be known what was installed and whether it still works as required.

Original text of the legal act

The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.

The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania

Official Gazette of Romania no. 890 of 23 October 2026, pages 2-10 16 pages PDF, 145 KB the act starts on page 2

Open the official PDFDownload the PDF

The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.