In brief

  • A European regulation takes the place of the directive on which the whole of Romanian return law was built. Regulation (EU) 2026/2280 was published in the Official Journal of the European Union, L series, of 15 October 2026, enters into force on 16 October 2026, and from that date only a short list of articles applies. The return procedure itself applies only from 17 October 2027.
  • On 16 October 2026 nothing changes for a person found to be staying illegally in Romania. That day only the scaffolding goes up: the designation of competent authorities, agreements with third countries, the best interests of the child and age assessment, readmission, and support from the European Border and Coast Guard Agency (Frontex). Until 17 October 2027, Directive 2008/115/EC and Government Emergency Ordinance no. 194/2002 on the regime of foreign nationals in Romania remain in force.
  • From 17 October 2027 the figures that decide how long a deprivation of liberty may last change. Placement in public custody, the Romanian form of detention, may reach 24 months, plus a further six months at most under certain conditions, so 30 months in all, against 18 months in the directive being replaced and in Romanian law. The entry ban rises to 10 years, and to 20 years in justified cases, against the five-year rule in the directive. The period within which a return decision may be challenged before a court may no longer exceed 14 days.
  • Romania has to rewrite its ordinance on foreign nationals. Article 82 of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 194/2002, which prohibits the return of persons over 65, of the spouse of a Romanian citizen and of the parent of a child with Romanian citizenship, is left without support in Union law: the regulation takes over neither the clause on more favourable national provisions nor the residence permit granted on humanitarian grounds.
  • The preparation window is 367 days, from publication to full application. For the „European Return Order” form the European Commission has until 17 April 2027. Mutual recognition rests on it, that is the piece through which a decision issued in Timișoara becomes readable and enforceable in Lisbon or in Tallinn.
Act: Regulation (EU) 2026/2280 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 7 October 2026 establishing a common system for the return of third-country nationals staying illegally in the Union, and repealing Directive 2008/115/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council, Council Directive 2001/40/EC and Council Decision 2004/191/EC
Published: Official Journal of the European Union, L series, of 15 October 2026
In force from: 16 October 2026, the day following publication, under Article 50(1)
Applies from: 16 October 2026 for the provisions listed in Article 50(2), 17 October 2027 for all the others

For 18 years, every decision requiring a foreign national to leave Romania has rested, in the last analysis, on Directive 2008/115/EC. Government Emergency Ordinance no. 194/2002 on the regime of foreign nationals in Romania transposed it, and the Romanian courts read it through that filter. That directive is now repealed.

In its place comes Regulation (EU) 2026/2280, adopted at Strasbourg on 7 October 2026 and published in the Official Journal of the European Union, L series, of 15 October 2026. The difference is not one of content but of nature: a directive is transposed into national law, while a regulation applies directly. The closing paragraph of the act says so without hedging: the regulation „shall be binding in its entirety and directly applicable in the Member States”. The Romanian authorities will apply the European rule directly, and the Romanian text that repeated it loses its purpose. The ordinance on foreign nationals stays in play only for what the regulation leaves to national law.

The second thing a reading of Article 50 makes clear is that nothing happens all at once. The regulation enters into force on 16 October 2026, but from that day only Article 1, Article 2(1), (2) and (3), Article 3, point (3), Article 4, Article 5(13) and (15), plus Articles 14, 15, 16, 34, 35, 41, 43, 47, 48 and 49 apply. All the other provisions, that is the return procedure, the entry ban, detention, the obligations of the person, the safeguards and the remedies, apply from 17 October 2027. That is also the date on which the three repealed acts cease to have effect, under Article 49(1).

What it changes in practice

For someone found to be staying illegally in Romania on 16 or on 17 October 2026, the procedure stays as it is today: the General Inspectorate for Immigration issues the return decision under Article 83(1) of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 194/2002, the decision may be challenged within 10 days before the Court of Appeal under Article 85(1), and public custody is ordered for 30 days by the designated prosecutor at the Prosecutor’s Office attached to the Bucharest Court of Appeal, with extensions decided by the Court of Appeal. On the same subject, Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/2284, which activates a new type of alert in the Schengen Information System on third-country nationals.

What does start on 16 October 2026 has real effects, only on the State rather than on the person. Article 41 requires Romania to designate the authorities competent for the obligations arising from the regulation, which means an internal decision on who does what: issuing the decision, setting the country of return, assessing the risk of a breach of the principle of non-refoulement, ordering detention. Article 43 opens the way to requests for Frontex support, while Articles 34 and 35 set out readmission and the pressure on third countries that do not cooperate, including by making visa policy, trade and development conditional.

Article 14, which also applies from 16 October 2026, is probably the most debated. It allows return to a third country that is neither the country of origin, nor the country of former residence, nor one in which the person has a right to enter, provided that an agreement is concluded with that country. The agreement has to set out the procedures, the conditions of stay there, the obligations of the third country and the consequences of breaching it, and where it provides for onward return to the country of origin it also requires an independent monitoring body. Paragraph (5) prohibits sending unaccompanied minors by this route. From 16 October 2026 Romania has the legal basis to negotiate such agreements, with an obligation to inform the European Commission and the other Member States before they enter into force.

The deadline that matters most for the administration also starts running on day one: by 17 April 2027 the European Commission has to adopt the implementing act establishing the „European Return Order” form. Without that form, mutual recognition of decisions has no technical support, because Article 7(1) says that enforcement of a decision issued by another Member State „shall be based on the information available in the European Return Order”.

What has changed compared with the previous situation

The comparison with Directive 2008/115/EC, in the form published in the Official Journal of the European Union, L 348 of 24 December 2008, shows where the balance moves.

The voluntary departure period. Article 7(1) of the directive required „an appropriate period for voluntary departure of between seven and thirty days”, and paragraph (4) allowed that period to be cut below seven days, or refused altogether, only in three named situations: a risk of absconding, an application for legal stay dismissed as manifestly unfounded or fraudulent, and a risk to public policy. Article 5(2) of the regulation keeps the ceiling of 30 days but deletes the floor of seven days and makes the obligation to leave the territory immediately the second option of principle. The third subparagraph of the same paragraph leaves it to national law to set the situations in which a period is granted and those in which departure has to be immediate. The margin of appreciation moves, in practice entirely, to the Member State.

The entry ban. The directive said, in Article 11(2), that the length „shall not in principle exceed five years”, with the possibility of going beyond that only where the person represents a serious threat to public policy, public security or national security. Article 8(8) of the regulation sets the ceiling at 10 years and adds the possibility of a ban of up to 20 years „for duly substantiated reasons”, whenever this is considered necessary to prevent the person from entering. For persons covered by Article 13, the one on security risks, Article 13(5), point (a), even allows a ban of indefinite duration, with the right to ask for a review 10 years after departure. The list of cases in which the ban is mandatory grows as well: besides failure to comply with the obligation to leave, it now covers the simple fact that the person is subject to removal under Article 10, and that article also contains an open point (e), covering grounds other than those listed.

Detention. This is where the difference is largest. The directive set, in Article 15(5), a period which „may not exceed six months”, extendable under paragraph (6) by a further 12 months at most, so 18 months in all. Government Emergency Ordinance no. 194/2002 took over exactly those figures, in Article 101(6) and (7). Article 30(3) of the regulation starts at 12 months and rises to 24 months where the procedure is likely to last longer because the person does not cooperate, because of delays in obtaining documents, or in other exceptional circumstances provided for in national law. Paragraph (4) adds, after those 24 months, additional periods not exceeding six months in total, where there is a risk of absconding and a change in circumstances that makes removal possible again. The total climbs from 18 to 30 months, a rise of 12 months, that is by two thirds. For persons posing a security risk, Article 13(5), point (d), sets no ceiling at all: the additional periods are determined by a court and reviewed at least every three months.

What is new compared with the directive. Article 18 turns the person’s cooperation from an expectation into a detailed legal obligation, with 15 points, from handing over documents and biometric data to attending return counselling and appearing, in person or by videoconference, before the authorities of a third country. Article 19 sets out four situations in which the risk of absconding is presumed unless proven otherwise, and eight criteria for the overall assessment. Article 21 allows the person and the dwelling to be searched, electronic devices to be seized and coercion to be used, as a last resort, to take fingerprints. Article 22 lists the consequences of non-cooperation: reduction of certain benefits, refusal of a work permit, financial penalties, criminal sanctions including imprisonment, and extension of the entry ban up to the applicable maximum.

What is strengthened in the person’s favour. The remedy can no longer be entrusted to an administrative authority, as Article 13(1) of the directive allowed, but goes to a court, and Article 26(2) requires „a full examination of both points of fact and points of law”. Article 25(1) makes free legal assistance and representation mandatory on request in the judicial procedure, subject to the exceptions in paragraph (4). Article 31(2) requires the detention of unaccompanied minors to be reviewed ex officio at least every three months.

What disappears from the text. The correlation table in the Annex is the most candid part of the act, because it leaves the regulation’s column empty wherever a provision of the directive has no successor. Three absences matter. Article 4(1) to (3), the clause that allowed States to keep more favourable national provisions, has no equivalent. Article 6(4), the residence permit granted for compassionate or humanitarian reasons instead of a return decision, has no equivalent. And Article 5, which required States to take due account of the best interests of the child, family life and state of health, is sent to Article 4, a general clause on fundamental rights, and to Article 15, which covers only the best interests of the child. Family life and state of health remain written down explicitly only in Article 11(6), that is only for the period during which removal is postponed.

This is where the conflict with Romanian law arises. Article 82 of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 194/2002 prohibits a return measure against a minor whose parent has a right of residence in Romania, against the parent of a dependent child with Romanian citizenship, against the spouse of a Romanian citizen or of a long-term resident foreign national, and against a person over 65. Article 5(1) of the regulation requires the authorities to issue a return decision for „any illegally staying third-country national”, subject to the limited exceptions in Article 6, and the clause on more favourable provisions no longer exists. From 17 October 2027 the regulation prevails, because it applies directly and in its entirety. Article 82 will not be able to stand as a prohibition on issuing the decision; to produce the same result, the protection has to move higher up, into the rules that grant a right of residence, because a person with a right of residence is no longer staying illegally and falls outside the scope of the regulation.

Advantages and disadvantages

What it improves

  • The remedy against the return decision, against the entry ban and against the decision ordering removal must go to a court, with a full examination of the facts and of the law, rather than to an administrative authority, as the directive allowed.
  • Legal assistance and representation become free on request in the judicial procedure, and a refusal based on the lack of any prospect of success can itself be challenged separately before a court.
  • The detention of unaccompanied minors is reviewed ex officio at least every three months, and unaccompanied minors cannot be sent to third countries with which there is only a take-back arrangement.
  • The automatic suspensive effect provided by Romanian law in Article 85(3) of the ordinance on foreign nationals is untouched: Article 28(1) says explicitly that the regulation is without prejudice to national provisions that lay it down.
  • A Member State no longer has to start the procedure from scratch for someone who already has a return decision in another State, which shortens the time a person spends in uncertainty.

What remains a problem

  • The maximum length of deprivation of liberty rises from 18 to 30 months, and for persons considered a security risk any ceiling disappears, leaving only quarterly judicial review.
  • Detention is reviewed, as a rule, once every six months, instead of the „reasonable intervals of time” in the directive. An interval written as a figure is harder to argue against in court than an elastic standard.
  • Separation from ordinary prisoners, where detention takes place in a prison, was unconditional in the directive and becomes „to the extent possible” in Article 32(1).
  • Article 45 allows a Member State to decide on its own that it is in an emergency situation and to derogate, among other things, from the accommodation conditions for unaccompanied minors and families with minors, with no more than an obligation to inform the European Commission.
  • The notion of a vulnerable person triggers obligations of the State in five places in the regulation, yet it is no longer defined anywhere, and the definition in the directive has no successor.
  • Mutual recognition remains optional, but it comes with no financial compensation between Member States, because the decision that governed it is repealed without replacement.

Practical advice

  1. If you receive a return decision in Romania in 2026 or in the first half of 2027, the time limit for challenging it is the one in Romanian law, 10 days from notification, before the Court of Appeal. Do not go by the 14 days in the regulation: Article 27 applies only from 17 October 2027.
  2. Ask in writing for a translation of the main elements of the decision. Both Article 83(5) of the ordinance on foreign nationals and Article 5(11) of the regulation tie this right to a request, so it is not triggered on its own.
  3. Keep proof of every step of cooperation, from the passport application to attendance at counselling. From 17 October 2027, Article 5(4) allows the departure period to be extended for anyone who complies with the obligation to cooperate, while Article 22, point (d), allows the entry ban to be raised to the applicable maximum for anyone who does not.
  4. If you have left voluntarily, ask for the entry ban to be withdrawn or shortened and keep proof that you left. Article 9(1) ties this possibility to showing that the return was voluntary, and paragraph (5) allows States to make withdrawal conditional on reimbursement of the costs of removal.
  5. For employers and lawyers working with foreign nationals: check by 17 October 2027 whether your client’s situation falls under Article 82 of the ordinance on foreign nationals. The protection there has no counterpart in the regulation and will have to be rebuilt on another basis.
  6. For the authorities: the designation required by Article 41 cannot wait until 2027. The European Commission’s assessment of mutual recognition is due by 17 October 2029 and looks, among other things, at the burden placed on national judicial and administrative systems, that is at how well the transition was prepared.

Frequently asked questions

Does anything change for me from 16 October 2026?
If you are a person staying illegally, no. The provisions that concern you directly, from the return decision and the departure period to public custody and the remedies, apply from 17 October 2027, under Article 50(3). Until then, Directive 2008/115/EC and Government Emergency Ordinance no. 194/2002 remain in force.
Does this mean Romania will hold people in detention for 30 months?
Not automatically. Article 30(3) of the regulation is a ceiling, not an order: its wording is „shall not exceed” those periods. Romanian law keeps, for now, 6 months plus an extension of no more than 12 months, in Article 101 of the ordinance on foreign nationals, and a lower national ceiling remains compatible with the regulation. A decision to go up to 24 or to 30 months would be a Romanian political decision, not an obligatory consequence of the regulation.
Can another State refuse to enforce a return decision issued in Romania?
Yes. Article 7(1) says that the Member State where the person is „may” recognise and enforce another State’s decision, so recognition stays optional. If it does not recognise it, Article 7(3) requires it to issue its own return decision. The European Commission is assessing by 17 October 2029 how the mechanism has worked and may propose moving to mandatory recognition.
What is the European Return Order?
A standard form containing the main elements of the return decision and, where relevant, of the decision ordering removal. The European Commission establishes it by an implementing act, due by 17 April 2027, and States will use it when issuing the decision and make it available through the Schengen Information System. The recognition of decisions between Member States rests on it.
Does the regulation apply throughout the European Union?
No. Under recitals 67 and 68, Denmark is not taking part in its adoption and is not bound by it, and Ireland does not take part in the part of the Schengen acquis to which the regulation belongs. Iceland, Norway, Switzerland and Liechtenstein apply it through their Schengen association agreements. For Romania, the regulation is binding.
What happens to asylum applications?
Article 2(3) says that the regulation is without prejudice to Regulations (EU) 2024/1351, (EU) 2024/1348 and (EU) 2024/1349. In addition, Article 10(7) requires the authorities to direct the person to the appropriate procedure, including the asylum procedure, where relevant indications emerge that removal would breach the principle of non-refoulement.

Errors and inconsistencies in the published text

  • Article 3, the list of definitions. The notion of a „vulnerable person” produces obligations of the State in five places in the regulation, in Article 11(6), point (e), Article 20(2), Article 29(5), Article 32(4) and Article 44(5), point (e), including the obligation to examine vulnerability before ordering detention. Article 3 defines 11 notions, from „third-country national” to „return operation”, but it does not define this one, and the correlation table in the Annex shows Article 3, point 9, of Directive 2008/115/EC, the provision that listed minors, disabled people, elderly people, pregnant women, single parents with minor children and victims of torture or of serious violence, with nothing in the regulation’s column, that is without a successor. With no definition and no reference to another Union act, two authorities can apply different lists to the same person, and a pregnant woman or an elderly person may be treated as vulnerable in one Member State and not in another.
  • Article 50(2), read against Article 2. The list of provisions applicable from 16 October 2026 includes Article 2(1), (2) and (3), but not paragraphs (4) to (8). Paragraph (1) establishes that the regulation applies to third-country nationals staying illegally, while paragraph (4) is precisely the one that takes out of scope those refused entry at the border, those apprehended at an illegal crossing of the external border, those returned as a criminal law sanction and those subject to extradition. The literal result is that, between 16 October 2026 and 17 October 2027, Articles 14, 15 and 16, already applicable, also apply to persons who, from 17 October 2027, will fall outside the regulation. In the same period, paragraph (7), the guarantee of a minimum standard of treatment for the excluded categories, and paragraph (5), through which a State could formally opt to include them, both remain inapplicable.
  • Article 7(8), read against Article 50(2) and (3). The text requires Member States to start putting in place the preparatory steps for mutual recognition „by the date of adoption of the implementing act referred to in Article 5(13)”, that is by 17 April 2027 at the latest. Article 7 is not, however, in the list in Article 50(2), so it applies from 17 October 2027, six months after its own deadline has expired. The same construction appears in Article 5(16) and (17), which set obligations „by 17 October 2027” but become applicable on 17 October 2027 itself. That this is not a deliberate choice is clear from Article 5(15), which has the same kind of deadline and which was placed in the list of provisions applicable from 16 October 2026.
  • Article 7(9), point (b), read against Article 5(16). Under it, the European Commission has to assess „whether the legal and technical arrangements to ensure automated handling of the European Return Order referred to in Article 5(16) are put in place by the Member States”. Article 5(16) places that obligation on the Commission and the relevant Union agencies, not on the Member States, and recital 26 speaks of support given to the States, not of an obligation on them. The contrast with point (a) of the same paragraph, which refers to Article 5(15), where the Member States are named explicitly, shows that the two references are not interchangeable. The assessment is not a formality: under paragraph (10), the legislative proposal for moving to mandatory mutual recognition rests on it.

Editorial analysis

The regulation solves a real problem, and it solves it with the right instrument. A directive transposed in 27 ways produced 27 return procedures that did not recognise one another, and a decision issued in Romania meant nothing in Belgium. The standard form in Article 5(13), made available through the Schengen Information System, and the recognition in Article 7 attack exactly that point. Just as useful is that Article 26 takes the remedy out of the administrative sphere and brings it before a court, with a full examination of the facts and of the law, while Article 25 turns free legal assistance into an obligation rather than a possibility left to national law.

The price shows up in the proportions. The person is given at most 14 days to reach a court, under Article 27(1). The administration is given up to 913 days of detention, if the 24 months in Article 30(3) are added to the six months in paragraph (4). The ratio between the two periods is roughly 65 to 1. For persons covered by Article 13, detention has no ceiling at all. In between, mandatory review comes once every six months, under Article 31(1), that is at most five times over the 30 months. The directive gave no figure here, it required „reasonable intervals of time”, and the Court of Justice of the European Union was able to read that standard more demandingly than it will be able to read an interval written as a figure.

For Romania, the most substantial consequence lies not in the large figures but in a door that closes on 16 October 2026 itself. The second subparagraph of Article 27(1) allows a time limit for appeal of up to 30 days to be kept, but only for Member States which, by 16 October 2026, provided in their national law for time limits of 30 days or longer. Article 85(1) of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 194/2002, in the version consolidated on 27 April 2026, gives 10 days. Romania therefore falls outside the derogation and will never again be able to raise the time limit above 14 days, even if it wanted to. The 10 days now in force remain lawful, because the European ceiling is a maximum, but the room for improvement stops at 14 days, and the window for widening it closes on the day of entry into force, a year before the article becomes applicable.

The second Romanian consequence is the conflict with Article 82 of the ordinance on foreign nationals, described above, and it comes from two absences in the correlation table rather than from any new text: both the clause on more favourable national provisions and the residence permit granted on humanitarian grounds instead of a return decision disappear. The third concerns money. Decision 2004/191/EC, repealed by the same Article 49, set the criteria for offsetting the financial imbalances produced by mutual recognition of removal decisions, and the Annex leaves the regulation’s column empty. The State that enforces another State’s decision therefore bears the cost of the operation with no recovery mechanism, and the only avenue of recovery the regulation leaves open, Article 9(5), points towards the returned person, not towards the issuing State. For a State on the external border, with transit traffic, that is not an accounting detail.

What should be changed

  • The definition of a vulnerable person, put back into Article 3. Either by taking over the list in Article 3, point 9, of the repealed directive, or by an express reference to Directive (EU) 2024/1346, which the regulation already cites in Article 17(2). The practical effect: the authority deciding on detention would know whom it has to examine further, and the court would have a benchmark against which to check the decision.
  • Completing the list in Article 50(2) with Article 2(4) to (8). The scope should enter into force whole or not at all. In practice: during the transition year, the authorities would know exactly to whom Articles 14, 15 and 16 apply, instead of choosing between a literal and a systematic reading.
  • Moving Article 7(8) and Article 5(16) and (17) into the list of provisions applicable from 16 October 2026. The practical effect: the 12 months of technical preparation would be covered by an obligation in force, rather than by a deadline that expires before, or on, the day the obligation comes into being.
  • Putting family life and state of health back into Article 4. The directive listed them, in Article 5, among the elements to which States have to give due account at every step of the procedure. In the regulation they appear only in Article 11(6), that is only while removal is postponed. The consequence: the obligation to weigh them at the moment of the return decision would come back, rather than only after removal has been postponed.
  • A review interval for detention shorter than six months in Article 31(1), at least after the first year. Romanian law already reaches that result, through blocks of 30 days extended by the Court of Appeal under Article 101(4) of the ordinance on foreign nationals. What would change: real control over the length, instead of at most five checks in 30 months.
  • Making the derogations in Article 45 subject to a time limit and to an opinion. Emergency measures can now be taken „as long as the exceptional situation persists”, with no more than notification of the European Commission, and they can reach the separate accommodation of unaccompanied minors and families with minors. In practice: a maximum period and an opinion from the European Commission would keep the instrument for the situations it was designed for, without turning it into a parallel regime.
  • A compensation mechanism between Member States, in place of Decision 2004/191/EC. What would change: the State that enforces another State’s decision would recover the cost of the operation, and the mutual recognition in Article 7, optional today, would be used because it is efficient rather than avoided because it is expensive.

Original text of the legal act

The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.

The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania

Official Journal of the European Union, L series, of 15 October 2026 49 pages PDF, 1.1 MB

Open the official PDFDownload the PDF

The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.