In brief

  • The Constitutional Court dismissed as having become inadmissible the plea concerning Article 101 of the Tax Code, the article that set the tax on pensions, in the wording given by Law no. 282/2023 and applied from 1 January 2024. The reason is not that the text was sound, but that it could no longer be reviewed: by Decision no. 724 of 19 December 2024, published on 31 January 2025, the same article had already been declared unconstitutional in its entirety, and Article 29(3) of Law no. 47/1992 forbids a provision found unconstitutional from becoming the object of a further plea.
  • Who is affected. Recipients of pensions that also had a non-contributory component, that is to say service pensions, to which the graduated rates of 10%, 15% and 20% were applied, including those who had received pension differences and inflation adjustments awarded by final judgments and from whom tax was withheld on those amounts. The file brought together 105 cases from 20 tribunals, from Cluj to Tulcea.
  • What this means in practice: the cases are not lost. The Court states expressly that the decision by which Article 101 was declared unconstitutional also produces effects in these 105 cases, because every referral had been sent before that decision was published. Decision no. 48/2026 is final and generally binding from 6 October 2026.
Act: Decision of the Constitutional Court no. 48 of 20 January 2026 on the plea of unconstitutionality of the provisions of Article 101 of Law no. 227/2015 on the Tax Code, in the wording preceding the entry into force of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 11/2025 amending Law no. 227/2015 on the Tax Code
Published: Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 842 of 6 October 2026, pages 2-16
Delivered: 20 January 2026, by unanimous vote
Final and generally binding: 6 October 2026, the date of publication

One hundred and five lawsuits about the tax on pensions, gathered into a single file from 20 tribunals, closed at the Constitutional Court without the question put by the pensioners receiving an answer. The plea was dismissed as having become inadmissible, by Decision no. 48 of 20 January 2026, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 842 of 6 October 2026. The formula sounds like a defeat, but it is not: the contested text had already been taken out of play, 13 months earlier, by another decision of the same Court. It is a pattern that recurs often with service pensions, where the outcome depends on the date the file reached the Court, not only on what is written in it.

To understand what was judged, it must first be said what the article did. Article 101 of the Tax Code is headed „Calculation of the tax on income from pensions and the payment deadline” and was rewritten by Article XVIII of Law no. 282/2023, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 950 of 20 October 2023, applicable from 1 January 2024. From that moment, the tax on a pension was no longer calculated in the same way for everyone.

A pension earned entirely through contributions had a monthly tax-free threshold and a single rate of 10% above it. A pension that also had a non-contributory part, that is to say a service pension, was split in two: the contributory part was taxed at 10%, while the non-contributory part climbed in steps, 10% up to the level of the average net salary, 15% between the average net salary and the gross figure used in framing the state social insurance budget, and 20% above that gross figure. The same three steps also applied to pensions that were entirely non-contributory.

The difference few people noticed lies in the tax-free threshold. Law no. 244/2024, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 899 of 5 September 2024, raised it from 2,000 to 3,000 lei, but only under letter a), that is to say only for the purely contributory pension. Under letters b) and c), those covering pensions with a non-contributory component, the threshold remained 2,000 lei. For a service pensioner, that 1,000 lei gap meant, at the minimum rate of 10%, 100 lei more in tax each month, or 1,200 lei a year, than for a pensioner with the same pension earned through contributions.

Paragraph (8), the one that concerns pensioners who have won in court, read as follows: in the case of income from pensions and of differences in income from pensions, as well as of amounts representing their adjustment by the inflation index, awarded on the basis of final judgments, the tax is calculated separately from the tax on the current month’s entitlements, by applying the same rates, and is a final tax. It is withheld on the date of payment and transferred by the 25th of the following month. In practice, anyone receiving several years of differences in one go saw the sum taxed as a separate block, at the rates in force at the moment of payment.

The authors of the pleas challenged this whole mechanism. They argued that the split into steps is discrimination on grounds of wealth, that the text does not say clearly how the contributory part is calculated, for instance which contribution period applies to military personnel, 25 years or the 35 years of the general rules, and that the two reference points for the steps, the average net salary and the gross one, are indicators that change every year, so nobody can calculate their tax in advance. Their first criticism, however, was a different one: that Parliament had failed to bring the law into line with an earlier decision of the Court, Decision no. 467 of 2 August 2023.

What it changes in practice

The first effect, and the most important one for anyone with a pending case, is that the outcome does not leave them without a defence. The Court writes explicitly, in paragraph 130, that the decision by which Article 101 was found unconstitutional also produces effects in these cases, because it had been seised before that decision was published. The courts hearing the 105 files therefore apply the finding of unconstitutionality, not the dismissal. The formula „having become inadmissible” closes the review, not the right.

For anyone who wants to take the case further, the limit is drawn by the decision confirming that there is no appeal in cassation in pension disputes.

The second effect is that none of the substantive criticisms was examined. Discrimination on grounds of wealth, the vagueness of the indicators, the contribution period of military personnel, the separate taxation of differences awarded by a judgment: all of them remain unanswered in this decision. Anyone who wanted reasoning on these points has to read it in Decision no. 724 of 19 December 2024, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 91 of 31 January 2025.

The third effect is the mechanism itself, which is worth understanding once, because it keeps recurring. Under Article 29(3) of Law no. 47/1992, provisions found unconstitutional by an earlier decision of the Constitutional Court cannot be the object of a plea. When a plea sets off lawfully but the contested text is struck down by another decision between the referral and the ruling, the plea does not become wrong, it becomes devoid of object. That is what „having become inadmissible” means, and that is where it differs from a plea simply dismissed as inadmissible, which was never properly framed in the first place.

The fourth effect is one of timing, and it explains why the contested text no longer exists. Under Article 147(1) of the Constitution, provisions found unconstitutional are suspended by operation of law and cease to have legal effect 45 days after the decision is published, unless Parliament or the Government brings them into line with the Constitution by then. The 45 days running from 31 January 2025 expired on 17 March 2025. Government Emergency Ordinance no. 11/2025 was published and entered into force on 13 March 2025, that is on the 41st day, four days before the deadline.

The fifth effect concerns those who have no case pending. For them, nothing changes on 6 October 2026: the applicable tax regime is the one in force since 13 March 2025, and today’s decision concerns a text that is no longer in force.

What has changed compared with the previous situation

The substantive change lies in the ordinance mentioned in the title of the decision. Until 13 March 2025, Article 101 had nine paragraphs and two taxation regimes, with the three steps of 10%, 15% and 20% on the non-contributory part. After Emergency Ordinance no. 11/2025, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 225 of 13 March 2025, the article has six paragraphs and a single rate: the tax is calculated by applying a rate of 10% to the monthly taxable income from pensions. The steps are gone, and the splitting of the pension into a contributory and a non-contributory part went with them. Article 1011 was repealed.

A service pensioner reads the difference in two figures. On the non-contributory part above the average gross salary, the rate fell from 20% to 10%, so it was halved. On the part between the average net salary and the gross one, it fell from 15% to 10%, a third less.

What did remain is the rule for money won in court. The former paragraph (8) was rewritten and moved down to paragraph (6): for pensions, pension differences and inflation adjustments awarded by final judgments, the tax is still calculated separately from that on the current month, is a final tax, is withheld on payment and transferred by the 25th of the following month. The novelty is that the new text expressly adds interest awarded in connection with those amounts. The rate applied, however, is now the single rate of 10%.

It should also be said where the whole chain begins. On 2 August 2023, by Decision no. 467/2023, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 727 of 7 August 2023, the Court carried out a review before promulgation of the law that became Law no. 282/2023. It then declared several texts of the law unconstitutional, among them Articles I to IV, Article XV and three annexes, but Article XVIII, the one on the tax, was not among them. In the same decision, in paragraphs 165 to 168, the Court set out the criteria that the taxation of pensions must observe: fairness, proportionality, reasonableness and non-discrimination, with an obligation on the legislature to establish the taxable income, the amount due and the method of calculation with particular care. The law was published 74 days later, with Article XVIII unchanged. A further 426 days on, on 19 December 2024, that same article fell.

Advantages and disadvantages

What it improves

  • The 105 cases are not lost: the Court states expressly that the finding of unconstitutionality also produces effects in them, because the referrals preceded its publication.
  • Joining 105 files into a single one produced an identical outcome for all the authors, instead of 105 decisions delivered on different dates.
  • The decision clarifies, for the future, the difference between a plea that is inadmissible from the outset and one that becomes inadmissible along the way.
  • The outcome is unanimous, and the bench was the nine-judge one, the Court’s full complement.
  • On the substance of the problem, the graduated taxation of service pensions has not existed since 13 March 2025, and the single rate of 10% is easier for a pensioner to check.
  • The rule for money won in court has survived and now expressly covers interest as well, not only the inflation adjustment.

What remains a problem

  • None of the substantive criticisms received an answer in this decision, although the file runs to 131 paragraphs.
  • Between delivery, on 20 January 2026, and publication, on 6 October 2026, 259 days passed, and the decision only produces effects from publication.
  • The regime declared unconstitutional was actually applied for 396 days, from 1 January 2024 until the publication of Decision no. 724/2024, and then remained suspended by operation of law for a further 41 days.
  • The tax-free threshold was raised to 3,000 lei only for the purely contributory pension, and those with a service pension stayed at 2,000 lei until the text was struck down.
  • The decision says nothing about how overwithheld tax is to be recovered, so each file goes back to its own tribunal without any common guidance.
  • Eight of the 20 tribunals failed to give their opinion in at least one of their files, although Article 29(4) of Law no. 47/1992 obliges them to, invoking the risk of prejudging the case.

Practical advice

  1. If you have a pending case in which you raised this plea, do not read „dismissed” as a defeat. Check the date on which the court sent the file to the Constitutional Court: if it precedes 31 January 2025, your case benefits from the unconstitutionality of Article 101, under paragraph 130 of the decision.
  2. Ask for Decision no. 724 of 19 December 2024, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 91 of 31 January 2025, to be added to the file if it is not there already. That is where the substantive reasoning is, not in today’s decision.
  3. Check your pension slip and your payslips for the period from 1 January 2024 to 13 March 2025 to see which rate was applied to you and to which part of the pension. The difference between 20% and 10% on the same amount is the sum at stake.
  4. If you received pension differences awarded by a judgment during that period, ask the payer for a breakdown of the tax withheld. Paragraph (8) required the calculation to be separate from the current month’s entitlements, so the withholding must appear separately.
  5. For payments made after 13 March 2025, the correct rate is the single rate of 10%, and the rule on amounts won in court has moved to paragraph (6) of Article 101.
  6. If you want to challenge a tax provision, first check whether it has already been declared unconstitutional. In such a case, Article 29(3) of Law no. 47/1992 makes the plea inadmissible from the start.

Frequently asked questions

What does „dismissed as having become inadmissible” mean?
It means that the plea was properly raised at the time, but that between the referral to the Court and the ruling the contested text was struck down by another decision of the Constitutional Court. Article 29(3) of Law no. 47/1992 forbids a provision already found unconstitutional from becoming the object of a plea, so there is nothing left to review. Here, the text was struck down by Decision no. 724 of 19 December 2024, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 91 of 31 January 2025, which concerned Article 101 in its entirety.
I have a pending case. Do I lose anything because of this decision?
No. In paragraph 130, the Court states that the finding of unconstitutionality also produces effects in cases where it was seised before that finding was published, which is true of all 105 joined files. The court hearing your file applies the unconstitutionality of Article 101.
What exactly was taxed, and at what rate?
A pension earned through contributions was taxed at 10% above the tax-free threshold. A pension with a non-contributory component, that is to say a service pension, was split: 10% on the contributory part and 10%, 15% or 20% on the non-contributory part, depending on how it compared with the average net salary and with the gross figure used in framing the state social insurance budget.
How were pension differences won in court taxed?
Under paragraph (8), separately from the tax on the current month’s entitlements, at the same rates and as a final tax, withheld on the date of payment. The rule also covered amounts representing the adjustment by the inflation index. After Emergency Ordinance no. 11/2025, the rule sits in paragraph (6) and expressly includes interest as well.
Which rate applies to pensions now?
A single rate of 10% on the monthly taxable income from pensions, since 13 March 2025, the date on which Government Emergency Ordinance no. 11/2025 entered into force. The steps of 15% and 20% and the splitting of the pension into a contributory and a non-contributory part no longer exist in Article 101.
Why were 105 files gathered into a single one?
Because they had the same object. On the basis of Article 53(5) of Law no. 47/1992, the Court ordered them to be joined to the file registered first, no. 2.498D/2024. The cases came from 20 tribunals, most of them from the Bucharest Tribunal, with 39 files, and from the Cluj Tribunal, with 15.
Do I have to take any step to recover tax that was overwithheld?
Decision no. 48/2026 lays down no procedure and says nothing about money. Guidance on making good the loss is to be found in Decision no. 724/2024, and each person’s situation is settled in their own file, at the tribunal that sent it to the Court.

Editorial analysis

Today’s decision is the longest of the day and, at the same time, the emptiest: of its 131 paragraphs, 127 recite who raised the plea, from which court, in which file and what that court’s opinion was, while the Court’s own reasoning fits into three, paragraphs 128 to 130. This is not a reproach addressed to the Court, because the mechanism demands it: when the contested text disappears, the Court has nothing left to judge. It is, however, a measure of the cost. The 105 files were opened, parties were summoned, reporting judges drew up their reports and the files were then joined, and the result is a finding that Article 29(3) of Law no. 47/1992 had required since 31 January 2025. Between delivery, on 20 January 2026, and publication, on 6 October 2026, 259 days passed. The decision it rests on, no. 724/2024, was published within 43 days of being delivered. The same institution needed six times longer for the simple decision than for the complicated one.

The second observation emerges from comparing the letters of the article that was struck down. Under Law no. 244/2024, the monthly tax-free threshold rose from 2,000 to 3,000 lei, but only under letter a), that is to say only for a pension earned entirely through contributions. Letters b) and c), the very ones covering the categories before the courts, stayed at 2,000 lei. For a service pensioner, the 1,000 lei gap meant, even at the lowest rate, 100 lei a month and 1,200 lei a year more than for a pensioner with the same amount earned through contributions. The September 2024 amendment therefore widened precisely the gap that was being contested, four months before the article fell.

The third observation concerns the speed of work at the opposite ends of the same mechanism. On 7 August 2023, by Decision no. 467/2023, the Court set out the criteria that the taxation of pensions must observe and required the legislature to take particular care in establishing the taxable income and the method of calculation. Law no. 282/2023 was published 74 days later, with Article XVIII untouched, and entered into force on 1 January 2024. The text produced effects for 396 days, until the publication of Decision no. 724/2024, and then remained suspended by operation of law for a further 41 days. The Government repaired the article on 13 March 2025, on the 41st of the 45 days allowed by Article 147(1) of the Constitution, with four days to spare. The rhythm is the same every time: the deadline is met at the last moment, while the period during which the taxpayer pays under an unconstitutional rule is counted in hundreds of days.

The last observation concerns the courts. Eight of the 20 tribunals, among them Bucharest, Cluj, Satu Mare, Botoșani and Iași, failed to give their opinion in at least one of the files they sent, although Article 29(4) of Law no. 47/1992 requires it, and some explained that taking a position would amount to prejudging the case. The opinions of those that did reply are unevenly split: some tribunals considered the plea well founded, citing Decision no. 467/2023 itself, others considered it unfounded, and one tribunal proposed a reading of the text. On a provision applied uniformly across the country, this divergence shows that the vagueness invoked by the authors was not a figure of speech.

What should be changed

  • A maximum deadline for publishing the Constitutional Court’s decisions. The 259 days between delivery and publication are days in which the tribunals cannot apply the outcome, and the files sit still. A deadline of 30 days, with the possibility of a reasoned extension, would close the gap.
  • Automatic stay of cases challenging a text already contested before the Court. If files were joined to the first one registered as a matter of course, rather than at the hearing, the 104 referrals sent after the first would no longer each run the full course of summonses and reports.
  • The operative part should say what happens to the cases, not only what happens to the plea. Today the essential point, that the finding of unconstitutionality also applies in these files, sits in paragraph 130, and anyone who reads only the operative part understands exactly the opposite.
  • A mechanism for refunding, as a matter of course, tax withheld on the basis of a text declared unconstitutional. Pension payers know the amounts withheld month by month, so recalculation is an administrative operation, not a lawsuit to be won one by one.
  • The court’s duty to give its opinion should carry a consequence. Article 29(4) of Law no. 47/1992 is drafted as an obligation, yet eight tribunals sidestepped it without consequence. A missing opinion deprives the Court of a point of reference and leaves the party with a thinner file.
  • Changes to a tax threshold should apply to every letter of the same paragraph. Raising the threshold under letter a) alone, in September 2024, widened the contested gap in the middle of the proceedings and could have been avoided with a single sentence in the amending law.

Original text of the legal act

The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.

The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania

Official Gazette of Romania no. 842 of 6 October 2026, pages 2-16 16 pages PDF, 108 KB the act starts on page 2

Open the official PDFDownload the PDF

The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.