In brief
- The state advances in full the fees and charges of a civil case if the average monthly net income per family member over the last two months is below 1,081.25 lei, and half of them if it is below 2,162.50 lei. The two thresholds in Article 8 of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 51/2008 are 25% and 50% of the national minimum gross base salary, which since 1 July 2026 has been 4,325 lei. In the first half of 2026, with the minimum salary at 4,050 lei, the thresholds were 1,012.50 lei and 2,025 lei.
- The aid comes in four forms: a lawyer, an expert or translator, a bailiff, and relief on court fees, from outright exemption to payment in up to 48 monthly instalments. The first three share a single ceiling of 10 national minimum gross base salaries a year, which is 43,250 lei as at October 2026. Relief on fees, including exemption from the court stamp duty, falls outside that ceiling.
- The decision published on 27 October 2026 nevertheless reviews the fixed threshold of 300 lei, which left the statute book on 15 January 2023. The Constitutional Court unanimously dismisses the plea and finds that Article 6, Article 8(1) and Article 14(1), together with the emergency ordinance as a whole, are constitutional. No rule changes and no right arises out of the decision.
- The application for public legal aid is exempt from stamp duty, is heard without summoning the parties, and a refusal can be challenged within 5 days. The request for review is decided by a different panel, by an order that cannot be challenged further. Where aid is sought for an appeal, the time limit for an appeal or an appeal on points of law is interrupted once only, provided the supporting documents are filed within 10 days.
- 1,925 days passed between the referral to the Court and the publication of the decision, and the text upheld had been out of force for 3 years and 285 days by the date of publication. The plea was raised in a case registered in 2015, the Bucharest Tribunal referred the matter to the Court on 20 July 2021, the decision was delivered on 9 December 2025 and published on 27 October 2026, that is 322 days later.
Published: Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 898 of 27 October 2026, pages 2-5
Delivered: 9 December 2025, unanimously
Final and generally binding: 27 October 2026, the date of publication
Someone on a low income who is party to a civil case can ask the state to pay for the lawyer, the expert, the bailiff and the stamp duty, but only if the net income of each family member stays below a quarter of the minimum gross salary, which means below 1,081.25 lei since 1 July 2026. That threshold was confirmed indirectly by the Constitutional Court in Decision no. 715 of 9 December 2025, published on 27 October 2026, which dismisses as unfounded the plea of unconstitutionality raised against Article 6, Article 8(1) and Article 14(1) of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 51/2008 and against the ordinance as a whole. It is the second decision on the same income thresholds to be published in two months: in Decision no. 169/2026, published on 4 September 2026, the Court upheld exactly the same limits of 300 and 600 lei, stating expressly, in the title of the decision, that the text reviewed was the one preceding Law no. 31/2023.
That statement in the title is precisely what separates the two decisions. Decision no. 715/2025 reproduces Article 8(1) in the present tense, in the version with the fixed threshold of 300 lei, and nowhere says that the text has since been replaced. A reader acting in good faith who opens the issue of 27 October 2026 to find out how much they can earn without losing the aid will find a figure that the courts have not applied since January 2023.
The figures that do apply are derived from the minimum salary. Article 8(1), in the version given by Law no. 31/2023, grants aid advanced in full by the state to people whose average monthly net income per family member over the two months preceding the application falls below 25% of the national minimum gross base salary, while paragraph (2) grants half the amounts where income falls below 50%. The minimum salary has been 4,325 lei since 1 July 2026, under Government Decision no. 146/2026, so the thresholds are 1,081.25 lei and 2,162.50 lei. For applications made between 1 January and 30 June 2026, with the minimum salary at 4,050 lei, they were 1,012.50 lei and 2,025 lei.
The plea came from a married couple, Iosif and Constanța Puiu, in a case before the Bucharest Tribunal, Fourth Civil Division, whose very subject matter was an application for public legal aid in the form of exemption from the court stamp duty on their notice of appeal. Their criticisms came on two levels. On extrinsic grounds, they argued that the Government could not legislate by emergency ordinance in a field reserved to statute by Article 139(1) of the Constitution, and that it had encroached on fundamental rights, which Article 115(6) forbids. On intrinsic grounds, they attacked the income threshold as a discriminatory criterion and the list of documents in Article 14(1) as an additional obstacle to access to justice, adding that the rules lacked foreseeability.
The Court rejected each criticism, drawing on its own case law. Court fees may be imposed by ordinance because the phrase „numai prin lege”, only by statute, in Article 139(1) excludes instruments ranking below statute, namely government decisions and ministerial orders, not ordinances. Free access to justice does not mean that the service provided by the courts is free of charge: the rule is that claims bear stamp duty and the exceptions are those the legislature lays down. Setting the eligibility conditions falls to the legislature, which chooses the range of people entitled to state support. The documents required by Article 14(1) were imposed for transparency and for the sound administration of the fund, not as an obstacle. And the foreseeability of a rule is assessed in the context of the regulation as a whole, not article by article.
On the exemptions from court fees, the Court ruled separately, in Decision no. 623/2025, that counties and communes pay court stamp duty when the case is not about public revenue.
What it changes in practice
The decision is final and generally binding from 27 October 2026, the date of publication, under Article 147(4) of the Constitution, which the operative part itself cites alongside Article 146(d). The most important practical effect is that nothing changes, and that is precisely the news. A dismissal as unfounded removes no rule from the legal order and does not retouch its meaning: Article 6, Article 8(1) and Article 14(1) remain applicable exactly as they were, in their current version, and the emergency ordinance stays in force as a whole.
For anyone filing an application for public legal aid after 27 October 2026 the test is unchanged: the average monthly net income per family member over the two months preceding the application is calculated and compared with 1,081.25 lei for full aid and with 2,162.50 lei for half of it. Under Article 9, the calculation takes in all periodic income, but also the sums owed periodically for basic needs, such as rent and maintenance obligations. Family is defined in Article 5: the spouse, the children and other dependent descendants in the direct line up to the age of 18, those over 18 but under 26 if they are still in education, plus any person who shares the applicant’s home and household.
The thresholds are not the only way in, and the decision touches neither of the other two. Article 8(3), in the version given by Law no. 268/2024, allows aid to be granted in other situations as well, in proportion to the applicant’s needs, where the certain or estimated costs of the case are liable to limit their effective access to justice, measured against the income earned and the expenditure proved. Article 8^1 grants aid irrespective of means, where a special statute provides for free legal assistance as a protective measure, in situations such as minority, disability or a particular status.
The extrinsic part of the decision has the broadest effect, even though it goes unnoticed. By upholding the ordinance as a whole against Article 115(6) and Article 139(1) of the Constitution, the Court closes off the route for challenging the Government’s very choice to regulate public legal aid by emergency ordinance and, by extension, the relationship between court fees and the reservation of matters to statute. Article 29(3) of Law no. 47/1992 only bars a plea from being raised again on texts already found unconstitutional, so a fresh plea on the same articles is not inadmissible out of hand, but the Court has ruled on these same provisions at least three times in two years, in Decisions no. 118/2025, no. 169/2026 and no. 715/2025.
For the case itself, the decision is served on the Bucharest Tribunal, Fourth Civil Division. Article 29 of Law no. 47/1992 does not provide for the case to be stayed while the plea is being decided, so the couple did not spend those 1,925 days with their proceedings halted, but their application for exemption from the stamp duty on the appeal was settled long before the Court answered.
What has changed compared with the previous situation
The text the Court reviewed was replaced by Law no. 31/2023 amending Government Emergency Ordinance no. 51/2008, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 38 of 12 January 2023 and in force from 15 January 2023. The law removed the two fixed amounts, 300 lei for full aid and 600 lei for the 50% version, and tied them to the national minimum gross base salary, at 25% and at 50%. In the same pass it rewrote Article 7, which caps the cumulative value of the aid in the forms listed in Article 6(a) to (c) at 10 national minimum gross base salaries a year, rewrote Article 9 on how income is established, and repealed Article 16(2) and Article 22(1).
The new mechanism has an effect that becomes visible only once the figures are lined up. When the emergency ordinance was adopted, on 21 April 2008, the national minimum gross base salary was 500 lei, under Government Decision no. 1.507/2007, so the threshold of 300 lei was 60% of the minimum salary and the one of 600 lei was 120%. The amounts then stayed untouched for almost 15 years, while the minimum salary rose sixfold. By 1 January 2023, with the minimum salary at 3,000 lei, the threshold of 300 lei had fallen to 10% of it and the one of 600 lei to 20%. In other words, the range of people entitled had narrowed sixfold without a single article being amended. Law no. 31/2023 lifted the thresholds to 750 lei and 1,500 lei overnight, and automatic indexation has since brought them to 1,081.25 lei and 2,162.50 lei.
The second significant amendment is Law no. 268/2024, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 1089 of 31 October 2024 and applicable from 3 November 2024. It opened public legal aid to non-profit legal persons established in Romania as well, in the cases laid down by statute, where they act without any personal interest to defend the rights of people in special situations or to protect a group interest. It introduced, in Article 8(3), the route proportionate to the applicant’s needs, including for differences in the cost of living between the country of residence and Romania. And it added, in Article 11(4), an obligation that matters more than it appears: at the first hearing for which the parties have been lawfully summoned, the court informs them that they may apply for public legal aid and of the conditions and specific forms in which it can be sought.
Measured against the Court’s own case law, the decision brings nothing new and claims nothing else. Paragraph 30 states explicitly that no new elements have arisen that would call for the case law to be reconsidered, so both the reasoning and the solution are carried over. The only novelty lies in paragraph 31, where the Court answers separately the criticism of foreseeability raised under Article 1(5) of the Constitution, which the earlier decisions on Article 8 did not address. The answer is that the clarity of a rule is examined in the context of the regulation as a whole, and that absolute precision would produce excessive rigidity.
Advantages and disadvantages
What it improves
- The thresholds have moved with the minimum salary on their own since 15 January 2023, so no fresh statute is needed to keep them from falling behind. The last adjustment came automatically on 1 July 2026, when the minimum salary rose to 4,325 lei.
- Not a leu is charged for the application itself: it is exempt from stamp duty under Article 12(2), so someone who cannot afford the fee does not need money in order to ask to be excused from it.
- The annual ceiling of 10 minimum gross salaries, that is 43,250 lei as at October 2026, covers only the fees of the lawyer, the expert, the translator, the interpreter and the bailiff. Exemptions, reductions and instalment arrangements for court fees under Article 6(d) stay outside it, so a case with heavy stamp duty does not use up the ceiling.
- Aid can be applied for at any point during the proceedings and is maintained throughout the procedural stage for which it was sought, under Article 12(1).
- Where there is an appeal, Article 13(3) interrupts the time limit for an appeal or an appeal on points of law once only, provided the supporting documents are filed within 10 days, and a fresh period starts running from service of the order. Where the aid takes the form of assistance by a lawyer, the bar association must appoint one within 48 hours.
- A refusal is not final on the spot: the request for review is made within 5 days of service and is heard by a different panel, not the one that refused.
- Anyone who meets the income conditions and has been through mediation before the proceedings or before the first hearing recovers the fee paid to the mediator, under Article 20.
- Court fees can be spread over as many as 48 monthly instalments, and where the fees exceed twice the monthly net family income, the instalment is calculated so that it does not exceed half that income.
- Since 3 November 2024 the court has had to inform the parties at the first hearing of their right to apply for public legal aid, so the information no longer depends on how well someone knows their own rights.
What remains a problem
- The threshold is calculated as a percentage of the gross minimum salary, while the applicant’s income is measured net. For a family of four, full aid requires a total net income below 4,325 lei, that is below a single gross minimum salary, and half-aid requires below 8,650 lei, which is below two gross minimum salaries.
- Measured in minimum salaries, the entry threshold is 2.4 times tighter than when the ordinance was adopted: 25% instead of 60%. Keeping the 2008 proportion would put the threshold, in October 2026, at 2,595 lei per family member instead of 1,081.25 lei.
- The decision upholds a figure that no longer applies. The threshold of 300 lei had been out of the statute book for 3 years and 285 days by the date the decision was published, and the published text nowhere says which version was reviewed.
- The time lag makes the review almost useless for the people who raised the plea: 1,603 days from the referral order to the ruling and another 322 to publication.
- The application is heard without the parties being summoned, in chambers, and the review the same way. At no point does the applicant get to explain out loud why their figures do not tell the whole story.
- The risk of getting an application wrong is out of all proportion: if the court finds bad faith through concealment of the truth, Article 17(2) requires the sums to be repaid and imposes a fine of up to 5 times the amount for which the exemption was obtained.
- The aid is not an outright transfer. If the beneficiary loses the case, the costs advanced by the state remain, as a rule, borne by the state, but the court may order full or partial repayment for want of diligence or for an abuse of process.
- For applications filed in the first half of 2026 the thresholds were 1,012.50 lei and 2,025 lei, because the increase in the minimum salary only applied from 1 July. Anyone refused in June who would have qualified in July has no way of reopening the matter, since aid is granted from the date the application is made.
Practical advice
- Work out the average monthly net income per family member for the two months preceding the application, not for the last year and not for your best month. Compare the result with 1,081.25 lei for full aid and with 2,162.50 lei for half, for as long as the minimum salary stands at 4,325 lei.
- Count the family correctly, because each member brings the average down. It includes dependent children up to 18, those between 18 and 26 who are still in education, and the person you share a household with, even if they are not a relative.
- Deduct what you have to pay out periodically. Article 9 requires account to be taken of sums owed periodically for basic needs, among them rent and maintenance obligations, so a monthly rent is not a detail to leave out of the file.
- If your income is only just over the threshold, do not give up: apply under Article 8(3). The text allows aid to be granted in proportion to your needs, where the certain or estimated costs of the case limit effective access to justice, measured against income and proven expenditure.
- When you apply for aid for an appeal or an appeal on points of law, file the application with the court whose judgment you are challenging, within the time limit for that appeal, and get your supporting documents ready in advance: the time limit is interrupted once only, and the interruption works only if you file the documents within 10 days.
- Include in the application, from the outset, the sworn statement about aid received over the past 12 months, with its form, the case and the amount. Article 14(1) requires it expressly, and leaving it out sends your file back just when the deadlines are short.
- Put 5 days from service of the refusal order in your diary. The review is heard by a different panel and is decided by an order that cannot be challenged further, so it is your only chance to correct a calculation or a missing document.
- If you expect heavy stamp duty, ask for instalments, not just exemption. Where the fees exceed twice the monthly net family income for the preceding month, the monthly instalment cannot exceed half that income, and payment can be spread over up to 48 months.
- If a special statute gives you a right to free legal assistance, for minority, disability or a particular status, rely on Article 8^1 and leave out the income calculation: there, aid is granted irrespective of means, but only for the rights connected with the special situation.
- Do not build your application on the figure of 300 lei that you will find in the decision of 27 October 2026 or in older decisions of the Court. The applicable text is the one given by Law no. 31/2023, and a file drawn up on the old threshold is refused without discussion.
Frequently asked questions
What income thresholds are in force?
Why does the decision talk about 300 lei?
What forms can public legal aid take?
What do I do if my application is refused?
Does the state give me the money or lend it to me?
Can I apply if my income is slightly over the threshold?
Can an association or a foundation receive public legal aid?
What do I risk if I declare a lower income?
Does the decision change anything for me?
Errors and inconsistencies in the published text
- Paragraph 13, page 3: the text of Article 8(1) is reproduced in the present tense in its repealed version, and the operative part upholds the article without saying which version. The text introduces the challenged provisions with the formula „care au următorul conținut normativ”, which have the following normative content, and quotes Article 8(1) in the version with a fixed threshold of 300 lei per family member. That version was replaced by point 2 of Article I of Law no. 31/2023, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 38 of 12 January 2023, with the wording „sub nivelul echivalentului a 25% din salariul de bază minim brut pe țară”, which keys the threshold to a quarter of the national minimum gross base salary, applicable from 15 January 2023, that is 3 years and 285 days before the decision was published. Neither the title of the decision nor any paragraph mentions the amendment, and the operative part on page 5 finds that „dispozițiile art. 6, ale art. 8 alin. (1) și ale art. 14 alin. (1)” are constitutional, with no marker of version, even though the decision is generally binding from publication under Article 147(4) of the Constitution. Reviewing the version in force on the date of referral is natural and follows the constitutional court’s usual practice. The flaw lies elsewhere: the published text makes it impossible to establish what exactly was upheld, the threshold of 300 lei or the one of 25% of the minimum salary, which by October 2026 stood at 1,081.25 lei. The contrast can be checked in the same field: Decision no. 169 of 26 February 2026, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 750 of 4 September 2026, carries in its title the words „în redactarea anterioară modificărilor aduse prin Legea nr. 31/2023”, that is, the version preceding that amendment. Article 29(1) of Law no. 47/1992 also requires the plea to concern a provision „în vigoare”, in force, and the decision does not show why that condition is met for a text replaced almost three years before the ruling.
- Paragraph 30, page 5: the reasoning carried over is attributed to a „decizia menționată”, the decision referred to, which the text does not identify. The closing sentence of the analysis says that, since no new elements have arisen, „atât considerentele, cât și soluția pronunțată în decizia menționată sunt aplicabile și în prezenta cauză”, both the reasoning and the solution in the decision referred to apply in the present case as well. Up to that point, the Court cites eight of its own decisions in its reasoning: no. 462/2019, no. 299/2001, no. 649/2014, no. 109/2011, no. 118/2025, no. 39/2015, no. 264/2009 and no. 187/2017. The singular cannot be matched to any of them without the reader making a choice, and the reasoning of a decision of the Court is binding to the same extent as the operative part. A court that later invokes „the reasoning of the decision referred to in paragraph 30” has no way of knowing which reasoning it is taking over.
Editorial analysis
On the merits, the outcome is correct and predictable. None of the criticisms raised could have succeeded: court fees are budget revenue set on the conditions laid down by law, an emergency ordinance is legislation in the substantive sense, and the income threshold is, by its very nature, a policy choice bounded by the resources of the fund administered by the Ministry of Justice. The Court also answers the criticism of foreseeability, which earlier decisions in the same field did not address, and it does so with the right argument: the clarity of a rule is examined in the context of the regulation as a whole, and an exhaustive list of situations would make the text unworkable the first time an unforeseen case came along.
The problem with this act is not the outcome, it is the snapshot it leaves in the Official Gazette of Romania (Monitorul Oficial). A decision of the Constitutional Court is not only an act of justice between the parties, it is also a source of information for anyone reading the law, and here the figure that reaches the reader’s eye in October 2026 is one that no court has applied since January 2023. That it could have been done differently is shown by the Court’s own practice: Decision no. 169/2026, delivered on 26 February 2026, that is 79 days later than this one, was published after only 190 days from the ruling, on 4 September 2026, 53 days ahead of it, and carries the version reviewed in its very title. The same Court, the same ordinance, the same article, two ways of identifying the object of the review.
The observation that does not emerge from reading the act end to end is a different one, and it explains why the threshold under attack had become so small. When Government Emergency Ordinance no. 51/2008 was adopted, on 21 April 2008, the national minimum gross base salary was 500 lei, under Government Decision no. 1.507/2007, so the threshold of 300 lei meant 60% of the minimum salary and the one of 600 lei meant 120%. The two amounts went untouched until 15 January 2023, while the minimum salary reached 3,000 lei: the threshold of 300 lei came to represent just 10% of the minimum salary, a proportion six times smaller than at adoption. In 2021 the authors of the plea attacked a criterion that had nothing discriminatory about it when it was adopted and had become almost impossible to meet through the mere passage of time. The Court had no instrument to put that right, because the range of beneficiaries is for the legislature, but nor does it say so anywhere, and without these figures a dismissal looks like confirmation that a threshold of 300 lei is reasonable in 2026.
The second calculation missing from all these decisions is the one the reader makes when wondering whether they qualify. The threshold is expressed as a percentage of the gross minimum salary, while the applicant’s income is measured net, and the count is made per family member. For a family of four, full aid requires the household’s entire net income to be below 4,325 lei, that is below a single gross minimum salary, while 50% aid requires below 8,650 lei, or below two. Had the 2008 proportion been kept, the entry threshold in October 2026 would be 2,595 lei per family member, more than twice the real one. The indexation mechanism stopped the erosion, but it froze it at the level reached in 2023, not at the 2008 level.
A third imbalance lies in the relationship between the time limits imposed on the applicant and those that the administration of constitutional review allows itself. Someone seeking an exemption for an appeal has 10 days to file the supporting documents, failing which the interruption of the time limit does not operate, and 5 days to challenge a refusal. On the other side, 1,603 days passed between the referral order of 20 July 2021 and the ruling, and another 322 between the ruling and publication, 1,925 days in all. No provision of Law no. 47/1992 sets a time limit for deciding a plea or for publishing the decision, even though it is publication that starts the generally binding effect running.
What should be changed
- The version of the text under review should be stated in the title and in the operative part of the decision, not just in some cases. The constitutional court already uses the formula, in Decision no. 169/2026, and it would be enough for it to become a drafting rule. In practice: a lawyer or a court searching the Official Gazette of Romania would see from the first line whether the decision covers the text applicable today or the one applicable in the case from which the plea came.
- Where the provision under review has been amended between referral and ruling, the decision should state expressly why it remains within the Court’s jurisdiction. Article 29(1) of Law no. 47/1992 requires a provision „în vigoare”, in force, and the reason the old version is nonetheless examined, namely that it continues to produce effects in the case, should be written out in a paragraph rather than assumed. The consequence: the same text could no longer be read as suggesting either that the Court exceeded its jurisdiction or that the repealed threshold is still applicable.
- Paragraph 30 should name the decision whose reasoning it takes over, with the number, the date and the place of publication. Taking it over through „the decision referred to”, after eight decisions have been cited, defeats the very mechanism that makes reasoning binding. The result would be that a court later faced with the same question could cite the exact source, rather than a reference it has to guess at.
- The thresholds in Article 8 should be set against the net minimum salary rather than the gross one, or the applicant’s income should be measured gross. As drafted, the text compares quantities of a different nature and sets the bar lower than it sounds: a quarter of the gross minimum salary is, in spending money, less than a quarter of what someone paid the minimum wage actually receives. Aligning the two bases would let an applicant verify the threshold with a single division, with no interpretation needed at panel level.
- The legislature should set an entry threshold keyed to the poverty line or to the net minimum salary, not to the percentage inherited from 2023. The 25% figure reproduces the level the eroded fixed amount had fallen to, with no published assessment behind it. A recalibration, even at the same overall cost, would distribute the fund differently, for instance by raising the 50% threshold that governs half-aid.
- The ceiling in Article 7 should be extended expressly, or expressly excluded, for the form of aid in Article 6(d). As it stands, the limit of 10 gross minimum salaries is written only for points (a) to (c), and a hurried reader applies it to exemption from stamp duty as well. One clarifying sentence would spare both applicants and the finance departments of the tribunals a calculation done two different ways.
- Law no. 47/1992 should be given a time limit for publishing a decision after it is delivered, 30 days for instance. The generally binding effect runs from publication, so delay shifts the moment from which the outcome becomes binding on everyone and goes beyond a question of internal administration. The 322 days in this case would become impossible, and a decision delivered later would no longer appear in the Official Gazette of Romania before one delivered earlier.
Original text of the legal act
The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.
The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania
Official Gazette of Romania no. 898 of 27 October 2026, pages 2-5 16 pages PDF, 121 KB the act starts on page 2
Open the official PDFDownload the PDF
The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.
