In brief
- The law was stopped before it ever existed. The Constitutional Court upheld the objection of unconstitutionality lodged by the High Court of Cassation and Justice and found, unanimously, that Article II of the law amending Law no. 51/1995 on the profession of lawyer is unconstitutional. The review took place before promulgation, so the text judged never entered into force.
- What Article II set out to change. Judges would no longer have been able to reduce of their own motion the part of the costs of the proceedings representing the lawyer’s fees. Reduction would have been possible only at the request of the interested party, only where the fee is „plătit disproporționat”, disproportionately paid, and with reasons tied to the criteria laid down in the legislation governing the profession of lawyer, that is to rules written in part by the National Union of Bar Associations of Romania (UNBR).
- Article 451 of the Code of Civil Procedure is left untouched. Judges keep the power to reduce the fee by a reasoned decision „chiar și din oficiu”, even of their own motion, where it is manifestly disproportionate to the value or complexity of the case or to the work done by the lawyer. The measure does not touch the relationship between a lawyer and his client.
- The door to reform stays open, on conditions. The Court says plainly that both models, reduction only on request and reduction of the court’s own motion or on request, can be constitutional, provided they come with objective criteria written into the law and with procedural safeguards for the party ordered to pay.
- Delivered on 1 July 2025, published on 15 October 2026. That is 471 days between the two moments, more than the 439 days that passed from the lodging of the objection to its delivery.
Published: Official Gazette of Romania (Monitorul Oficial), Part I, no. 863 of 15 October 2026, pages 2-12
Delivered: 1 July 2025, unanimously
Final and generally binding: 15 October 2026, the date of publication
A judge who sees in the file a lawyer’s fee out of keeping with the work behind it can reduce it without anyone asking. A law that had been waiting for promulgation since the spring of 2024 would have taken that power away and left reduction only at the request of the party ordered to pay. The Constitutional Court stopped it: by Decision no. 346 of 1 July 2025, published in Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 863 of 15 October 2026, it upheld the objection of the High Court of Cassation and Justice and found Article II of the law unconstitutional.
The review was one carried out prior to promulgation, that is on a law passed by Parliament but not yet promulgated. That changes how the outcome has to be read: a rule that was about to apply has been blocked, and the rule the courts have been using until now has stayed in place. For anyone with a case pending today, Article 451 of the Code of Civil Procedure works exactly as it did before. The same question, who may challenge a sum fixed by the court, arises for experts: a court expert can appeal a fee cut by the court.
What this means for the fate of the law is written in the Constitution. Where provisions are found unconstitutional before promulgation, Article 147(2) obliges Parliament to re-examine those provisions and bring them into line with the Court’s decision. The law cannot be promulgated with Article II in the form judged, and the Court states in paragraph 88 that it has no power to replace a defective rule with another itself. The decision is communicated to the President of Romania, to the presidents of the two Chambers of Parliament and to the Prime Minister. What Parliament decided after 15 October 2026 is not visible in the decision; the stage reached is checked in the bill’s file at the Chamber of Deputies and at the Senate.
The objection had reached the Court on 18 April 2024, under no. 3.748, and formed Case file no. 1.314A/2024. The hearings were adjourned 14 times, from the first date of 29 May 2024 until 1 July 2025, when the decision was delivered. No judge was left in the minority and the decision carries no dissenting or concurring opinion: the operative part shows a unanimous vote.
On 16 October 2026 the Constitutional Court upheld the minimum fine for building without a permit, with no option of a warning.
On 16 October 2026 the Ministry of Justice set out how sums from court judgments are paid in instalments to justice staff.
What it changes in practice
Article 451 of the Code of Civil Procedure remains in the form in force. Paragraph (2) keeps the word „poate”, may, together with the court’s power to order a reduction „chiar și din oficiu”, even of its own motion, on three statutory criteria: the value of the case, its complexity and the work done by the lawyer, plus the circumstances of the case. The same regime extends, through paragraph (3), to the fees of court-appointed experts and of specialists appointed under Article 330(3), while paragraph (4) excludes from reduction the court stamp duty, the judicial stamp and the sums due to witnesses.
Promulgation is not possible with Article II as it was voted. Re-examination in Parliament becomes compulsory for the provisions found unconstitutional, and until then nothing in Article II applies.
The decision is final and generally binding from 15 October 2026, the date of publication, and takes effect only for the future. There are no cases to reopen and no judgments to reassess, for the simple reason that the blocked text never produced any legal effect.
A less obvious effect has to do with what was left outside the operative part. The Court notes in paragraph 60 that it had not been expressly seised of Article I point 1 of the law under challenge, the point that introduced into Article 30(1) of Law no. 51/1995 the presumption that the fee agreed between lawyer and client is proportionate to the value or complexity of the case. The reasoning condemns the effect of that presumption, combined with Article II, as a „probatio diabolica” for the party ordered to pay. The operative part, however, reaches only Article II.
For the future of reform, the decision leaves the way open. Paragraphs 48, 52 and 83 say that both legislative solutions, reduction exclusively on request and reduction of the court’s own motion or on request, may be adopted without any defect of unconstitutionality, as long as the law at the same time limits the court’s discretion through objective criteria that are determined or determinable and accompanies the choice with effective procedural safeguards.
What has changed compared with the previous situation
The comparison runs between the text of Article 451 in force and the one Article II of the law would have put in its place, reproduced in full in paragraph 20 of the decision.
From a power of the court to a duty on request. The form in force says the court „poate”, may, reduce the fee, even of its own motion. The form proposed said the court „va reduce, la cererea părții interesate”, shall reduce, at the request of the interested party. The words that disappeared were not „poate” but „din oficiu”: the judge was still bound to reduce, but only if someone asked, and without a request he had no means of stepping in at all.
From „vădit disproporționat” to „plătit disproporționat”. The change looks cosmetic and is not. The form in force turns on a fee that is manifestly disproportionate, that is on the sum claimed as costs of the proceedings. The form proposed turned on the payment actually made. The Court explains in paragraphs 79 and 80 what that means: the law attached itself to the payment having to be disproportionate rather than to the fee negotiated, implying that a lawyer may also be paid outside the contractual framework, and the opposing party could have challenged only the mismatch between the sum paid and the sum agreed in the contract.
The criteria moved out of the code and into professional rules. The new text added a sentence: the reasons for the measure „se va raporta la criteriile prevăzute de legislația profesiei de avocat pentru stabilirea onorariului”, would be tied to the criteria laid down by the legislation on the profession of lawyer for setting the fee. The Court found in paragraph 56 two possible readings of that reference, either to Law no. 51/1995 alone or also to the Statute of the Legal Profession and the other rules of the UNBR, and held the provision to be unclear. The difference in substance is not a small one: the law offers the judge three criteria, while Article 127(3) of the Statute lists nine elements, among them the lawyer’s standing and reputation, the client’s financial situation and the advantages obtained for him.
A remedy appeared, but an incomplete one. The reduction was to be challenged together with the merits and, in the case of judgments open to appeal on a point of law and of final judgments, through an application for re-examination decided by a different panel of the same court. The text did not say within how many days the application is to be made, how it is decided and what outcomes the panel seised of it may reach. What is more, the remedy was open only to the party whose costs had been reduced, not also to the one whose application for reduction had been dismissed.
Two different regimes inside the same article. The proposed paragraph (3) kept for court-appointed experts and specialists the wording „la cererea părții interesate sau din oficiu”, at the request of the interested party or of the court’s own motion. The judge would therefore have kept the power to intervene on his own over an expert’s fee and would have lost it over a lawyer’s fee, in the same judgment and on the same head of costs.
Advantages and disadvantages
What it improves
- The losing party keeps a safeguard it does not have to ask for. If it is absent from the hearing on the merits or has asked for the case to be heard in its absence, the judge can still act alone on the fee claimed by the other side.
- Reform remains possible. The Court says explicitly, in paragraphs 48 and 83, that the „only on request” model can be constitutional, if the law accompanies it with objective criteria and procedural safeguards.
- The Court comes down from principle to examples. Paragraph 90 lists criteria the legislature could use: the minimum fee set by the bar association, the minimum or average wage in the economy, the average of the fees charged in the field, the criteria for increases in the Statute of the Legal Profession, including the drafting of pleadings, research and documentation, and secretarial work.
- The limit of the profession’s own power is drawn clearly. Paragraphs 66 and 70 say that procedural rules concerning the effects of the exercise of fundamental rights may be enacted only by Parliament or by the Government, and that the representative bodies of lawyers are not among the authorities entitled to regulate them.
- It is confirmed that reduction does not touch the contract. The court’s measure concerns only how much of the fee the opposing party bears, not the relationship between a lawyer and his client.
What remains a problem
- The grievance that produced the law does not go away. Reductions of the court’s own motion are made on three broad criteria, and how predictable they are depends on each panel. The Court itself accepts, in paragraph 90, that „orice lege este perfectibilă”, every law can be improved, and that the legislature may introduce objective criteria binding on the judge.
- There is no ceiling on the fee negotiated. Paragraph 59 finds that lawyer and client cannot go below the minimum fees set by the UNBR but can go as high as they like, because the law lays down no upper limit. The only brake for the party ordered to pay remains the judge’s assessment.
- The presumption in Article I was not judged. It stays in the text of the unpromulgated law, and a re-examination touching only Article II can bring it into force without the procedural counterweight the reasoning calls for.
- The decision sets no deadline for re-examination. The law can stay suspended in Parliament indefinitely, with no one in default.
- The 471 days between delivery and publication held the law in legal limbo. The fate of Article II had been settled since 1 July 2025, yet Parliament could not re-examine and the President could not promulgate, because the effects begin at publication.
Practical advice
- If you have a case pending, change nothing in your strategy on costs. The text of Article 451 in force applies unchanged, with reduction possible of the court’s own motion as well.
- Build no application and no defence on the new form of Article 451. The text never entered into force and cannot be relied on as positive law.
- If you are claiming costs of the proceedings, file the legal assistance agreement, the receipts and the itemised breakdown of services no later than the close of the debate on the merits. Article 452 of the Code of Civil Procedure leaves no time limit after that moment.
- If you risk being ordered to pay the costs, ask in good time for the other side’s application and the evidence filed with it to be served on you, instead of relying on the judge stepping in. Paragraph 78 of the decision describes the trap exactly: the evidence can be filed in the last second of the last hearing.
- If you have asked for the case to be heard in your absence, weigh the cost of that choice precisely on the head of costs. Being absent from the hearing leaves you with no practical way of contesting the amount claimed.
- When you challenge a fee, argue on the statutory criteria, that is the value of the case, its complexity and the work done, and set them against the elements in Article 127(3) of the Statute of the Legal Profession. The court works with the first three but can put them in context with the others.
- If you are following the fate of the law, open the bill’s file at the Chamber of Deputies and at the Senate. The compulsory re-examination shows up there, with a date and an adopted text, not in the Court’s decision.
Frequently asked questions
Did the law ever enter into force?
Can the judge still reduce a lawyer’s fee of his own motion?
What happens to the law from here on?
Did the Court say that reduction only at the party’s request is unconstitutional?
Were there any dissenting or concurring opinions?
Why is a decision of 1 July 2025 published on 15 October 2026?
Does the decision touch the contract between a lawyer and his client?
Who brought the matter before the Court, and why?
Editorial analysis
The law started from a real grievance, and the decision does not deny it. A judge cutting a fee of his own motion works with three broad criteria, and the result varies from one panel to another. The answer the law had chosen to give was, however, the most expensive one: instead of writing the criteria, it removed the control. The Court responds along the same line, but in reverse. In paragraph 83 it says that the judge’s power is a procedural safeguard only to the extent that the law at the same time limits his discretion through binding objective criteria, and in paragraph 90 it even sets out the list of criteria available. The problem that produced the law therefore remains unsolved after the law has fallen, because nobody has written the criteria.
The gravest incoherence in the text is visible in neither of the two paragraphs taken on its own, but in the relationship between them. The proposed paragraph (3) kept for experts and specialists a reduction „la cererea părții interesate sau din oficiu”, at the request of the interested party or of the court’s own motion, while paragraph (2) confined it to a request for lawyers. A court-appointed expert’s fee is framed by tariffs and by the subject of the expert report; a lawyer’s fee has no statutory ceiling, a point the Court makes explicitly in paragraph 59: below the minimums set by the UNBR one cannot go, but above them one can climb without limit. The judge’s power to intervene alone would have been kept exactly where the exposure is bounded and withdrawn exactly where it is unbounded. To this is added the difference in criteria: three in the Code of Civil Procedure, nine in Article 127(3) of the Statute of the Legal Profession, and the six additional ones, among them the lawyer’s reputation, the client’s financial situation and the advantages obtained for him, push the sum up rather than down.
The second observation concerns what was left outside the operative part. Paragraph 60 shows that the constitutional court had not been expressly seised of Article I point 1 of the law, the point introducing the presumption that the fee agreed is proportionate, while paragraphs 61, 63, 76 and 85 show that it is precisely the combination of that presumption with Article II that produces the impossible burden of proof for the party ordered to pay. The operative part reaches only Article II. If the re-examination is carried out strictly on what was declared unconstitutional, the presumption can enter into force in Law no. 51/1995 without the procedural counterweight the reasoning calls for, that is exactly the arrangement the decision describes as defective.
The third observation is one about time limits, and it is the only one that can be measured against a calendar. The Court reproaches the legislature, in paragraphs 15, 98 and 100, for not providing a period within which the application for re-examination can be made, because without a time limit access to the remedy becomes „incert și aleatoriu”, uncertain and random. Its own decision needed 439 days from the lodging of the objection to delivery, with 14 adjournments, and a further 471 days from delivery to publication, the only moment from which it takes effect. The longer part of the wait came after the solution had already been written. The operative part says only that the decision „se publică în Monitorul Oficial al României, Partea I”, without any time limit, and during those 471 days the law could be neither promulgated nor re-examined. The demand made of the addressee of the rule is missing from the Court’s own procedure.
What should be changed
- The criteria belong in the Code of Civil Procedure, not in a cross-reference. If the reference value, the limits and the elements of assessment sit in the code, the two possible readings found in paragraph 56 disappear, and the determination of procedural effects no longer depends on rules adopted by the bodies of a liberal profession, something paragraphs 66 and 70 forbid in any event.
- The re-examination should reach Article I as well, not only Article II. Otherwise the presumption of proportionality enters into force without the safeguards the decision calls for, and the party ordered to pay is left with the impossible burden of proof described in paragraph 77, even though Article II has been rewritten.
- A time limit and a procedure for the application for re-examination. The number of days, the manner of deciding and the outcomes the panel seised of it may reach have to be written into the text. Without them, the judge would be forced to settle them himself, case by case, and parties in identical situations would be given different rules.
- The same remedy for both parties. The party whose application for reduction is dismissed must have the same remedy as the party whose costs are reduced. Without that symmetry, the judgment is final for one and open to challenge for the other on exactly the same question.
- Service of the application for costs before the debate. A duty to file the application and the evidence a set number of days before the date of the debate would solve the problem in paragraph 78 without touching the judge’s power: the party would learn the amount in good time, and adjourning the case would no longer be the only way out.
- A publication deadline for decisions in review prior to promulgation. Where a whole law is left waiting, a delay in publication has a direct legislative cost. A short limit, of the order of days, would have taken the law out of suspension more than a year earlier.
Original text of the legal act
The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.
The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania
Official Gazette of Romania no. 863 of 15 October 2026, pages 2-12 16 pages PDF, 135 KB the act starts on page 2
Open the official PDFDownload the PDF
The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.
