In brief

  • A court-appointed expert can now appeal, alone, against the judgment that awarded less than the sum claimed. The High Court of Cassation and Justice (ÎCCJ) has ruled that, in the interpretation of Article 458 of the Code of Civil Procedure, an expert appointed by the court has standing to appeal against the judgment ruling on the expert’s request to increase the provisional fee. The ruling binds every court from 21 October 2026, the date of publication in the Official Gazette of Romania (Monitorul Oficial).
  • Two referrals, the same amount cut back to 2,500 lei. In the case before the Petroșani District Court the expert claimed 4,500 lei and received 2,500, after a provisional fee of 1,500 lei split equally between the parties. In the case before the Pașcani District Court the expert claimed 4,931 lei and again received 2,500. The reductions come to 44.4% and 49.3% of the fee statement respectively.
  • Practice was split inside the supreme court itself. The First Civil Division and the Administrative and Tax Litigation Division dismissed experts’ appeals as inadmissible, while the Second Civil Division allowed them. The decision aligns all three divisions on what had until then been the minority position, and the reporting judges had proposed, in the alternative, that the referral itself be declared inadmissible.
Act: Decision no. 87 of 21 September 2026 of the High Court of Cassation and Justice, Panel for the Resolution of Points of Law, delivered in Case no. 623/1/2026
Published: Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 883 of 21 October 2026, pages 9-16
Who it concerns: court-appointed technical experts, parties to civil proceedings who bear the cost of an expert report, lawyers, district courts, tribunals and courts of appeal
Takes effect: 21 October 2026, the date of publication, because Article 521(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure makes the decision binding on the courts from that date

A court-appointed technical expert who files the report and the fee statement, and then finds that the court has awarded half the sum claimed, has had a clear route open since 21 October 2026: the expert can lodge an appeal, or an appeal on points of law, against the judgment, without depending on either of the parties to the proceedings. The High Court of Cassation and Justice, sitting as the Panel for the Resolution of Points of Law, delivered Decision no. 87 of 21 September 2026, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 883 of 21 October 2026, allowing two joined referrals and settling the point of principle.

The exact wording of the operative part reads as follows: in the interpretation of Article 458 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the court-appointed expert has standing to appeal against the judgment by which the court ruled on the expert’s request to increase the provisional fee set at the outset. The words matter, because they cover a narrower situation than the one the referring courts started from.

The two case files behind the decision show how the problem works in practice. Before the Petroșani District Court, in a dispute between two neighbours over damages caused by flooding, the court ordered a building survey on 15 May 2024 and set a provisional fee of 1,500 lei, 750 lei payable by each party. On 15 October 2024 the expert filed the report together with a note assessing the final fee at 4,500 lei. At the hearing of 27 November 2024, at the parties’ request, the court fixed the final fee statement at 2,500 lei and ordered them to pay the difference of 1,000 lei over the provisional amount. The expert appealed, the Hunedoara Tribunal found in the expert’s favour by Decision no. 402 of 16 June 2025 and awarded the full 4,500 lei, and both the claimant and the defendant then brought an appeal on points of law against precisely that: a court had recognised a third party’s right to pursue a remedy.

Before the Pașcani District Court, in a dispute over the rectification of a title deed, the land surveying expert filed the work on 17 February 2025 with a final fee of 4,931 lei. By the interlocutory judgment of 11 March 2025 the court fixed it at 2,500 lei. The expert appealed, and the respondent county commission raised the plea of inadmissibility, arguing that Article 458 of the Code of Civil Procedure grants the right of appeal only to the parties to the proceedings.

What it changes in practice

The decision binds the courts from 21 October 2026, under Article 521(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure. That means a district court, a tribunal or a court of appeal can no longer dismiss as inadmissible an appeal brought by a court-appointed expert against the judgment ruling on the expert’s request to increase the provisional fee. The plea of inadmissibility, raised successfully until now before several panels, no longer has any object in this situation.

The legal mechanism by which the High Court reaches that result is the key for anyone who wants to apply the decision correctly. The supreme court does not say that the expert becomes a party to the dispute between claimant and defendant. It says that the request by which the expert seeks an increase in the provisional fee, made under Article 339(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure and Article 22(2) of Government Ordinance no. 2/2000, is a claim with a shape of its own, in which the expert stands as claimant and the party or parties liable for the fee stand as defendants. Within that claim, and only within it, the expert is treated as a party for the purposes of Article 458 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Three practical limits follow from this. First, the subject of the appeal is strictly the part of the judgment that directly concerns the expert, namely the expert’s monetary claim. The expert cannot attack the merits of the dispute between the parties, cannot reopen the conclusions of the expert’s own report and cannot use the appeal to obtain anything else. Second, the remaining provisions of the judgment become final if the parties do not challenge them, and the High Court states expressly that Article 477(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, on rulings dependent on the part under appeal, does not apply. The party that won the case can enforce the judgment even while the expert litigates the fee in parallel. Third, the ruling on the request for an increase is served on the expert under Article 427(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, whether the ruling is contained in an interlocutory judgment delivered earlier in the proceedings or in the final judgment, and the measure is enforceable under Article 339(2) of the same code.

For the party who pays, the effect is less welcome. Until now, if the court reduced the expert’s fee, the discussion ended there. From 21 October 2026 the same party can be summoned as respondent in an appeal brought by the expert, with a hearing date, a statement of defence and, if the case is lost, an obligation to pay the difference. The sum at stake is usually of the order of a few thousand lei, and in the Petroșani case the difference was 2,000 lei.

What has changed compared with the previous situation

Before this decision there was no single rule but three parallel practices, two of which were mutually exclusive. Even among the non-criminal divisions of the High Court of Cassation and Justice, according to Letter no. 178 of 8 May 2026 from the Legislation, Case-Law and Litigation Directorate, the First Civil Division held on appeal on points of law that the expert, not being a party, could not pursue a remedy against the judgment that had set or reduced the fee, and was left only with the procedure for supplementing the judgment. The Administrative and Tax Litigation Division took the same line. The Second Civil Division, by contrast, allowed the expert’s extraordinary remedy. The decision on the point of principle aligns every court with the position that was, until 21 October 2026, the minority one inside the supreme court.

The decision also shifts the legal basis on which the question was being discussed. The Alba Iulia Court of Appeal had framed its question around Article 458 read together with Article 451(2) and (3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the Petroșani District Court had in fact reduced the fee under Article 451(2). The High Court reformulates the question and states in its reasoning that Article 451(3) cannot be the legal basis for reducing the fee of a court-appointed expert: that provision covers the costs one party claims from the other, including the fees of party-appointed expert advisers engaged under Article 330(5) of the Code of Civil Procedure and Article 18 of Government Ordinance no. 2/2000, not the cost of taking evidence ordered by the court. For an expert appointed by random allocation, the amount is set under Article 331(2) and Article 339(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, read together with Articles 17, 22 and 23 of Government Ordinance no. 2/2000.

A second break with the past is explained by the High Court itself: under the 1865 Code of Civil Procedure, Article 274(2) prohibited judges from reducing the costs covering payment of experts. The current code removed that prohibition, and the question of the expert’s standing arose precisely out of that change. The argument also proved decisive for the novelty requirement that a referral must satisfy.

Finally, a difference between civil and criminal proceedings that was hard to justify now closes. Article 409(1)(e) of the Code of Criminal Procedure expressly provides that the expert may appeal in respect of judicial costs and the allowances due. In both procedures the fee is set on the same criteria drawn from Government Ordinance no. 2/2000, and the High Court finds that the civil or criminal nature of the dispute does not justify different outcomes.

Advantages and disadvantages

What it improves

  • From 21 October 2026 the court-appointed expert has a real procedural remedy against a reduction of the fee, not merely the procedure for supplementing the judgment under Article 444(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, which worked only where the court had failed to rule at all.
  • Practice is unified across three divisions of the supreme court that were deciding the same question differently, and the plea of inadmissibility can no longer be raised in the situation covered by the operative part.
  • The remedy is expressly confined to the financial element, so the dispute between claimant and defendant is not reopened on the merits because the expert has appealed.
  • The rest of the judgment stays final if the parties do not challenge it, because Article 477(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure is declared inapplicable. The winning party is not left with enforcement blocked.
  • The decision makes clear that reducing the fee of a court-appointed expert is not based on Article 451(2) and (3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, a provision that concerns party-appointed expert advisers.
  • The asymmetry with criminal proceedings disappears, where Article 409(1)(e) of the Code of Criminal Procedure expressly gives the expert a right of appeal on costs and allowances.
  • Service of the judgment on the expert under Article 427(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure becomes the point from which the expert can calculate the time limit, including where the ruling sits in an interlocutory judgment delivered earlier in the proceedings.

What remains a problem

  • The operative part covers only the situation of a request to increase the provisional fee. An expert whose fee the court reduced of its own motion, without any request for an increase, goes unmentioned, even though the decision acknowledges that this situation occurs.
  • The decision does not say which remedy lies and what the time limit is in each procedural configuration, and the wording in the reasoning about when the time limit starts to run is in the conditional.
  • The party who pays the fee becomes a defendant in an adjacent dispute, with defence costs capable of exceeding the amount in issue. In the Petroșani case the difference was 2,000 lei.
  • Duration is left untouched. The provisional fee in the Petroșani case was set on 15 May 2024, and the appeal on points of law in which the referral was made was still pending on 21 October 2026, more than 29 months later.
  • The decision does not address the real cause of the conflict, namely the undervalued provisional fee. Article 331(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure requires it to be set having regard to the expert’s estimates, yet in the Petroșani case the provisional 1,500 lei was fixed before the expert was asked, on 24 May 2024, for an estimated fee statement.
  • The criteria in Article 23(1) of Government Ordinance no. 2/2000 remain just as general. Both trial courts landed on exactly 2,500 lei, from fee statements of 4,500 and 4,931 lei respectively.
  • For judgments delivered before 21 October 2026 and already final on the finding of inadmissibility, the decision offers no mechanism of redress.

Practical advice

  1. If you are a court-appointed expert and the final fee is set below your fee statement, check first the date on which the judgment or the interlocutory judgment was served on you. The time limit for appealing runs from service, and service is mandatory under Article 427(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Make the request to increase the provisional fee in writing and expressly, under Article 339(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure and Article 22(2) of Government Ordinance no. 2/2000. The operative part of the decision is tied to that request, and without it the procedural position of claimant is harder to sustain.
  3. Break the fee statement down against the elements listed in Article 23(1) of Government Ordinance no. 2/2000: the complexity of the work, the volume of work in hours, the professional or academic qualification. In the Petroșani case the appeal court held precisely that the first-instance court had reviewed neither the 35 hours claimed nor the rate of 125 lei per hour.
  4. Keep the grounds of appeal strictly to the provisions on the fee. The decision says explicitly that the subject matter cannot be extended to the merits of the dispute between the parties, and an appeal that attacks anything else risks being dismissed in that part.
  5. If you are a party to the proceedings and the court has reduced the expert’s fee, allow for the possibility that the expert will appeal. Do not treat the sum set as final until the time limit, calculated from the service effected on the expert, has expired.
  6. When the expert report is ordered, ask the court to set the provisional fee on the basis of the expert’s estimate, as Article 331(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure requires. A provisional amount close to the real cost reduces the chances of a later dispute over the difference.
  7. If the court has omitted to rule on the fee altogether, use first the procedure for supplementing the judgment under Article 444(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure. Under Article 446, the supplementing judgment is subject to the same remedies as the judgment it supplements.
  8. Cite the decision by its number and date of publication, because it is binding from 21 October 2026. Judgments delivered before that date remain governed by the divergent practice the decision describes.

Frequently asked questions

From when does the decision apply?
From 21 October 2026, the date of publication in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 883. Article 521(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure provides that the resolution given to a point of law is binding on the courts from publication.
What exactly did the High Court rule?
That, in the interpretation of Article 458 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the court-appointed expert has standing to appeal against the judgment by which the court ruled on the expert’s request to increase the provisional fee set at the outset.
Does the expert become a party to the proceedings?
Not to the dispute between claimant and defendant. The expert becomes a party only to the expert’s own request for an increase in the fee, standing there as claimant, with the party or parties liable for the fee standing as defendants. The status of party is treated as such and confined to the expert’s monetary claim.
What can the expert challenge in the appeal?
Only the provisions of the judgment that directly concern the expert, that is the setting, the reduction or the refusal of the expert’s financial entitlements. The decision expressly excludes extending judicial review to the merits of the dispute between the parties.
Is the judgment suspended until the expert’s appeal is decided?
No. The other provisions become final if the parties do not challenge them, and the High Court shows that Article 477(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, on rulings dependent on the part under appeal, does not apply in this situation.
What happens if the court reduced the fee of its own motion, without the expert having asked for an increase?
The operative part of the decision does not expressly cover that situation. The National Institute of Magistracy argued in its submitted opinion that the solution holds there too, and the reasoning acknowledges that a reduction of the court’s own motion or at the parties’ request is possible, but the binding wording refers to the request for an increase.
When does the expert’s time limit for appealing start to run?
The reasoning ties the start of the time limit to service of the judgment on the expert, which is mandatory under Article 427(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, including where the ruling sits in an interlocutory judgment delivered earlier in the proceedings. The wording in the decision is, however, in the conditional, and the length of the time limit depends on the remedy available against the judgment under appeal.
Does it also apply to the fees of party-appointed expert advisers?
No. For those, Article 451(2) and (3) of the Code of Civil Procedure applies, and a reduction ordered by the court does not affect the contractual relationship between the party and the expert or specialist it nominated. The decision concerns the expert appointed by the court.
What happens to cases in which the expert’s appeal has already been dismissed as inadmissible?
Judgments that became final before 21 October 2026 are unaffected by the decision. The resolution is binding on the courts from publication and applies to pending proceedings.
Did the expert have any remedy before, if the court failed to rule on the fee?
Yes, the procedure for supplementing the judgment under Article 444(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, and under Article 446 the supplementing judgment is subject to the same remedies as the judgment it supplements. It was precisely that argument, and its logic, that weighed in the High Court’s ruling.

Errors and inconsistencies in the published text

  • The operative part against paragraph 99 and paragraph 69. The operative part refers exclusively to the judgment by which the court ruled on „cererea sa de majorare a onorariului provizoriu stabilit inițial”, the expert’s own request to increase the provisional fee set at the outset. Paragraph 99, however, describes two distinct situations, the request for an increase and the reduction of the provisional fee by the court „din oficiu sau la cererea părților”, of its own motion or at the parties’ request, while paragraph 69 shows that the National Institute of Magistracy expressly argued that the solution holds in the second situation too. The operative part does not take it up. An expert whose fee the court cut without any request for an increase having been made stays outside the binding resolution, and two courts can reach opposite conclusions: one dismisses the appeal as inadmissible because the situation is not covered, the other allows it by extending the reasoning in paragraphs 102 and 111. This is exactly the kind of divergence the decision was meant to prevent.
  • Paragraphs 93 to 95 against paragraphs 99 and 100. Paragraph 93 states that Article 451(2) and (3) of the Code of Civil Procedure „nu poate constitui temeiul juridic pentru reducerea onorariului provizoriu al expertului judiciar numit de către instanță”, cannot be the legal basis for reducing the provisional fee of a court-appointed expert, and paragraphs 94 and 95 confine the provision to the fees of party-appointed expert advisers. Paragraphs 99 and 100 nonetheless continue to accept that the court may reduce the fee, of its own motion or at the parties’ request, without indicating the basis on which it does so, and the only provision invoked there is Article 23 of Government Ordinance no. 2/2000, which lays down the assessment criteria, not a power to reduce. The interlocutory judgment of the Petroșani District Court of 27 November 2024, described in paragraph 17, rested precisely on Article 451(2). Two readings follow: either every interlocutory judgment of that kind is founded on a provision declared inapplicable, or the statement in paragraph 93 carries no practical consequence.
  • Paragraph 107 and the sentence that follows it. The passage on when the time limit for appealing starts to run is phrased in the conditional, „ar începe să curgă și termenul în care expertul poate exercita cale de atac, în condițiile legii”, the time limit within which the expert may pursue a remedy would also begin to run, as provided by law. For the person the rule addresses the question is not hypothetical: whether the appeal is in time or out of time depends on it. Nor does the decision say which remedy lies in each configuration, although paragraph 107 acknowledges that the ruling may appear in an interlocutory judgment delivered earlier in the proceedings or in the judgment disposing of the case, situations that do not carry the same regime. An expert acting in good faith cannot establish from the published text from when, and for how long, the remedy is open.

Editorial analysis

The decision settles the point of principle, and settles it convincingly, but leaves untouched the cause that generates the disputes. The figures from the two cases say more than the arguments: at Petroșani, a provisional fee of 1,500 lei, a fee statement of 4,500 lei, an award of 2,500 lei; at Pașcani, a fee statement of 4,931 lei, an award of 2,500 lei. Both trial courts landed on exactly the same round figure, from fee statements 431 lei apart. The reductions come to 44.4% and 49.3%. A threshold that turns up identically in two unrelated cases, in different fields of law and before district courts in different counties, looks more like a customary figure than the result of an assessment against the criteria in Article 23(1) of Government Ordinance no. 2/2000.

The second element invisible from the operative part concerns the arithmetic of the Petroșani fee statement. Paragraph 26 shows that the appeal court criticised the first-instance court for reviewing neither the 35 hours claimed by the expert nor the rate of 125 lei per hour. Those two figures give 4,375 lei, not 4,500. The difference of 125 lei, exactly one hour, is left unexplained in the published text, and the tribunal nonetheless awarded the whole amount in the fee statement. When a fee is cut by half without reasons, yet awarded in full without its components being checked, the problem is not the expert’s standing but the absence of a verifiable scale for both sides of the discussion.

The third element is the relationship between the time limits, and it is the hardest. The provisional fee in the Petroșani case was set on 15 May 2024, the contested interlocutory judgment dates from 27 November 2024, and the appeal on points of law in which the referral was made was still pending on 21 October 2026. That is more than 29 months from the setting of the provisional fee and almost 23 months from the interlocutory judgment under appeal, for a difference of 2,000 lei. In the Pașcani case, more than 19 months passed between the interlocutory judgment of 11 March 2025 and the date the decision was published, for 2,431 lei. The supreme court, by contrast, had the file from 26 March 2026 and ruled on 21 September 2026, with the hearing brought forward from 18 May, and publication followed 30 days after the ruling. The expert, by comparison, has a time limit for appealing measured in days, running from a service that the decision describes in the conditional.

The case-law map the decision rewrites also deserves a mention. Of the three non-criminal divisions of the High Court of Cassation and Justice, two, the First Civil Division and the Administrative and Tax Litigation Division, rejected the expert’s remedy, while one, the Second Civil Division, allowed it. The reporting judges had proposed, in the alternative, that the referral be declared inadmissible for want of novelty. The panel nonetheless went with the minority position, and rightly so, because the decisive argument is hard to counter: if Article 444(3) and Article 446 of the Code of Civil Procedure give the expert a remedy where the court forgets to rule, there is no procedural logic in denying one where the court does rule and awards less. The losers are the parties who pay the fee: they become defendants in an adjacent dispute, with defence costs that, on sums of 2,000 lei, can exceed what is at stake.

What should be changed

  • Adding an express clause on the expert to Article 458 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The solution would enter the text itself, on the model of Article 409(1)(e) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and would also cover the reduction made of the court’s own motion, which the operative part leaves out. Courts would no longer have to extend by interpretation a resolution drafted restrictively.
  • A named time limit and a named remedy in the text for the challenge over the fee. A single time limit, 15 days from service on the expert for instance, would remove the uncertainty in paragraph 107 and the risk of losing the right through lapse of time. In practice it would mean the expert no longer forfeits the remedy for having calculated the time limit under the regime of the main judgment rather than that of the interlocutory judgment.
  • A public hourly scale for court-ordered expert reports, revised annually by order of the Minister of Justice. The rate of 125 lei per hour in the Petroșani case was neither confirmed nor reviewed. With a published range per speciality, both the expert and the party would know in advance what is reasonable, and the court would have something to reason from. The number of disputes of this kind would fall at source.
  • A duty to give specific reasons for a reduction, item by item against the fee statement. If the court had to show which hour, which operation or which rate it was cutting, the repeated appearance of the figure of 2,500 lei would become impossible without justification. The appeal court could then actually review the decision, rather than merely note the absence of any reasoning, as happened in the Petroșani case.
  • A sanction for breaches of Article 331(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure when the provisional fee is set. The provisional fee of 1,500 lei was fixed on 15 May 2024, while the estimated fee statement was requested from the expert only by the letter of 24 May 2024. If the provisional amount had to be set only after the expert’s estimate, the difference of 3,000 lei that generated three levels of jurisdiction would never have arisen.
  • Payment of the final fee from public funds, with recovery from the unsuccessful party. The expert would be paid on filing the report, and the argument over the amount would be conducted between the State and the parties, not with the expert’s money tied up for 19 or 29 months. The model already works in criminal proceedings for the allowances due to participants.

Original text of the legal act

The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.

The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania

Official Gazette of Romania no. 883 of 21 October 2026, pages 9-16 16 pages PDF, 190 KB the act starts on page 9

Open the official PDFDownload the PDF

The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.