In brief

  • The enforcement proceedings lapse by operation of law, that is, they are extinguished without any further step, if 6 months pass in which the creditor fails, through his own fault, to perform the act the bailiff asked him for in writing.
  • The Constitutional Court has rejected the criticism that the wording „ce i-a fost solicitat, în scris” (which was requested of him, in writing) is unclear and leaves the bailiff unpunished. The text stays in force, unchanged.
  • The 6 months run from the date the request is served on the creditor, not from the date on which the bailiff drew it up.
Act: CCR Decision no. 152/2026
Published: Official Gazette of Romania (Monitorul Oficial) no. 708 of 26 August 2026
Delivered: 17 February 2026

A debtor tried to escape enforcement by arguing that a bailiff who lets a file sit cannot be held to account, and the Constitutional Court answered that the law gives him other levers. Decision no. 152/2026 of the Constitutional Court, published in Official Gazette of Romania no. 708 of 26 August 2026, rejects as unfounded the plea of unconstitutionality raised against the wording „ce i-a fost solicitat, în scris” (which was requested of him, in writing) in Article 697(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure. It is the second decision this year by which the Court confirms a mechanism belonging to the enforcement stage, after the one on territorial jurisdiction over complaints against offence reports.

The text under discussion is short and its consequences are large. Article 697(1) reads: „Where the creditor, through his own fault, has allowed 6 months to pass without performing an act or step necessary to the enforcement, ce i-a fost solicitat, în scris (which was requested of him, in writing), by the bailiff, the enforcement lapses by operation of law.”

The plea was raised by Ion Ciorac in a case before the Piatra-Neamț District Court, in an application to set aside enforcement by which he sought the annulment of the steps in the enforcement and a finding that the proceedings had lapsed. He argued that the rule lacks clarity, foreseeability and proportionality and that it does not penalise the fault of the bailiff: if the bailiff communicates nothing, the creditor is not at fault, and the lapse can no longer occur.

A day after this decision was published, the Court returned to the boundary between statute and administrative act, this time in environmental matters, through the decision on the law approving the National Biodiversity Strategy 2026-2030.

What it changes in practice

The first effect is the confirmation of the text. The wording stays in force, and the lapse of the enforcement proceedings continues to depend on a written request from the bailiff.

The second effect concerns the moment from which the 6 months run. Referring to its own case law, the Court explained that the period starts to run from the date on which the request is served on the creditor, not from the date on which it was drawn up. It is read together with Article 184 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The third effect is that the burden of moving the file stays with the creditor. The purpose of the rule, the Court says, is to make the creditor use every diligence in realising the rights obtained through the enforceable title.

The fourth effect concerns the position of the debtor. The Court holds that, as a rule, the debtor has no interest in seeing the enforcement against him completed, the only interested party being the creditor, so the lapse cannot be built on the debtor’s passivity.

The fifth effect is that it remains for the court to establish the actual date from which the period runs. The bailiff makes the request, but the court seised with finding the lapse determines the date.

The sixth effect is the list of remedies against a passive bailiff, which the Court sets out expressly: the application to set aside enforcement provided for in Article 712(1), second sentence, of the Code of Civil Procedure, the judicial fine and an order to pay damages under Article 720(7), plus the complaint to the district court provided for in Article 56 of Law No 188/2000 on bailiffs.

The seventh effect is that the decision is final and generally binding, so it applies to all courts, not only to the case in which the plea was raised.

What has changed compared with the previous situation

In law, nothing. The decision confirms a solution the Court had already given twice, by Decision no. 503 of 5 October 2023 and by Decision no. 573 of 31 October 2024, both rejecting similar criticisms of the same text.

What does become clearer is the position of a debtor who counts on the lapse. The argument that the bailiff cannot be penalised for passivity was set aside point by point, with the four legal remedies listed.

The relationship between the active role of the bailiff and the obligations of the parties also becomes clearer. The Court says that the contested provision gives expression to the active role of the bailiff, but that, to the same extent, the parties have to fulfil the obligations laid down by law.

What does not change is the mechanism: 6 months, fault on the part of the creditor, a written request from the bailiff, lapse by operation of law.

Nor does the test of the quality of the law change. The Court found the text to be clear, precise and foreseeable, and held that the person to whom the rule is addressed can adapt his conduct accordingly, so Article 1(5) of the Constitution is not infringed.

Advantages and disadvantages

What it improves

  • The rule stays foreseeable: the lapse cannot take by surprise a creditor who has received no written request.
  • The Court confirms that the period runs from service, which protects the creditor against a request left sitting in the bailiff’s file.
  • The list of remedies against a passive bailiff is useful to any party to an enforcement, not only to the author of the plea.
  • Since the decision is one of rejection, the practice of the courts does not change and pending files are not blocked.
  • The Court expressly links Article 697 to Article 184 of the Code, so the calculation of the period has a clear basis.

What remains a problem

  • The debtor stays dependent on the diligence of the creditor: if the creditor answers each request as a formality, the enforcement can last for years.
  • The remedies against a passive bailiff are real, but they call for separate proceedings, with costs and delay.
  • The Court does not settle what happens when the bailiff never makes a written request, a situation in which the lapse can never occur at all.
  • The decision was delivered in February 2026 and published only in August, so it became binding on everyone more than six months late.
  • The file sat at the Court from 2021, and the referral came out of a case begun in 2017.

Practical advice

  1. If you are the creditor and you receive a written request from the bailiff, note the date of service. The 6 months run from that date, not from the date written on the document.
  2. Answer every request from the bailiff in writing and keep the proof. The lapse occurs only for fault on the part of the creditor.
  3. If you are the debtor and you want to rely on the lapse, check first whether a written request from the bailiff exists and whether it was served on the creditor. Without it, the period does not run.
  4. The lapse is not established of its own motion. It has to be sought from the court, as a rule through an application to set aside enforcement.
  5. If the bailiff refuses to take a step in the enforcement, you have the application to set aside enforcement under Article 712(1), second sentence, of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  6. If the refusal is unjustified, you can lodge a complaint with the district court in whose area the bailiff’s office is located, under Article 56 of Law No 188/2000.
  7. The bailiff can be sanctioned with a judicial fine and ordered to pay damages, under the conditions of Article 720(7) of the Code.
  8. Do not rely on the mere passage of time. Without fault on the part of the creditor, the enforcement does not lapse, however long it takes.

Frequently asked questions

What does the lapse of the enforcement proceedings mean?
The extinction of the enforcement by operation of law when the creditor, through his own fault, has allowed 6 months to pass without performing an act or a step requested in writing by the bailiff.
When do the 6 months start running?
From the date on which the bailiff served the request on the creditor. The Court established this by Decision no. 503/2023 and repeats it here, reading it together with Article 184 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
What did the Court decide?
It rejected the plea as unfounded and found that the wording „ce i-a fost solicitat, în scris” (which was requested of him, in writing) is constitutional in relation to the criticisms raised.
Does anything change in practice?
No. The text stays unchanged, and the decision confirms the earlier case law of the Court.
What do I do if the bailiff does not move?
You have four routes: the application to set aside enforcement for refusal to take a step, the complaint to the district court provided for in Law No 188/2000, the judicial fine and an order requiring the bailiff to pay damages.
Can the debtor ask for the lapse?
Yes, but he has to prove that a written request from the bailiff exists, that it was served on the creditor and that 6 months passed without the creditor acting on it.
Does the decision apply only to the case it started from?
No. It is final and generally binding, so it applies to everyone.

Errors and inconsistencies in the published text

  • Paragraph 12: the reference to the precedent on which the solution rests leads to an edition that does not exist. The Court bases its rejection on two earlier decisions. The second reference is accurate: Decision no. 503 of 5 October 2023 is indeed in Official Gazette of Romania no. 259 of 26 March 2024. The first cannot be verified: the text indicates „Decizia nr. 573 din 31 octombrie 2024, publicată în Monitorul Oficial al României, Partea I, nr. 820 din 4 septembrie 2024” (Decision no. 573 of 31 October 2024, published in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 820 of 4 September 2024). Edition no. 820 of 2024 is dated 19 August 2024, not 4 September, and contains only reports on electoral income and expenditure from the Permanent Electoral Authority, no decision of the Constitutional Court. A decision delivered on 31 October 2024 could not, in any event, have been published in an edition from August of the same year. A reader who wants to check paragraphs 37 to 46, invoked as the basis of the solution, has nowhere to look for them.

Editorial analysis

The solution of the Court is correct and well reasoned. The criticism of the author of the plea started from a false premise: that the text leaves the bailiff unpunished. The Court answers point by point, listing four distinct remedies, one of which, the application to set aside enforcement for refusal to take a step, is written into the Code of Civil Procedure itself, in Article 712(1), second sentence. The argument that the rule is unclear falls as well: the mechanism has three visible elements, the written request, the fault of the creditor and the 6 month period, and the moment from which the period runs had already been settled in 2023.

The weak part is not the reasoning but the way it reaches the reader. The decision was delivered on 17 February 2026 and published on 26 August 2026, so it became generally binding more than six months later. For a decision of rejection the practical effect is small, but the delay remains a problem of the system: the parties in other cases raising the same plea waited for an answer that already existed.

The second observation concerns verifiability. A decision of the Constitutional Court draws its force from the references to its own case law, and here one of the two essential references cannot be followed. This is not a matter of form: paragraph 12 states expressly that the solution rests on paragraphs 37 to 46 of the decision cited wrongly, that is, on reasoning the reader cannot read.

The third observation is one of procedural calendar. The plea was raised in a case dating from 2017, the referral reached the Court through the judgment of January 2020, and the file bears number 3.110D/2021. Almost nine years passed between the events in the enforcement and the constitutional clarification.

What should be changed

  • Correction of the reference in paragraph 12, through a rectification published in the Official Gazette of Romania. It would give the reader back access to the precedent on which the solution rests, and rectifications of this kind are already established practice for published acts.
  • A maximum internal deadline between delivery and publication for the decisions of the Court. Six months for a three page text that confirms existing case law needlessly delays clarification in the related cases.
  • An automatic check of the pairing between decision number and publication reference, before the text is sent to the Official Gazette of Romania. The date of the edition and the date of delivery are two figures that can be compared mechanically, and a decision published before the day on which it was given is impossible by definition.
  • Clarification of the situation in which the bailiff makes no written request at all. In that case the lapse can never occur, and the enforcement can stay open indefinitely, which serves neither the creditor nor the debtor.

Original text of the legal act

The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.

The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania

Official Gazette of Romania no. 708 of 26 August 2026 16 pages PDF, 108 KB the act starts on page 2

Open the official PDFDownload the PDF

The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.