In brief
- The Constitutional Court dismissed the plea as unfounded and found that Article 170(3) of Law No 263/2010, the line stating that the correction index is applied only once, at the initial award of the pension, is constitutional.
- What decides a claim of this kind is not the type of the first pension but the law under which it was established. Anyone who first drew a pension from 2011 onwards, that is under Law No 263/2010, used the index once and does not receive it again when the pension becomes an old-age pension.
- What is at stake, in figures: the index for 2016 was 1.09 and the index for 2020 was 1.41. The ratio between them means a point score 29.4% higher, that is a larger pension every month, for the rest of the person’s life.
Published: Official Gazette of Romania (Monitorul Oficial) no. 768 of 10 September 2026
Delivered: 9 December 2025, unanimously
Final and generally binding: 10 September 2026, the date of publication
The Constitutional Court dismissed the claim of a pensioner from Caras-Severin who had asked for her correction index to be calculated at the date of her old-age pension rather than at the date of the partial early retirement pension she had taken four years earlier. By Decision no. 728 of 9 December 2025, published in Official Gazette of Romania no. 768 of 10 September 2026, the Court found that Article 170(3) of Law No 263/2010 is constitutional in relation to the criticisms raised. This is the third dismissal on the same line of the law in 15 months of rulings, after Decision no. 545 of 29 October 2024 and after Decision no. 124/2026, published on 8 July 2026.
The correction index is a number by which a person’s average annual point score is multiplied when the pension is established. It has nothing to do with indexation, which protects the pension against inflation and is repeated year after year. The correction index was designed as a remedy for a single event: from 1 January 2011, Law No 263/2010 increased the full contribution period, that is the number of years by which the points gathered over a working life are divided. Dividing the same points by more years gives a lower point score and, at the end of the calculation, a smaller pension. The index brings the figure back up. The same remedy came up again a few days later, in a decision holding that the index differs from one year of retirement to another and is not updated afterwards.
The contested provision runs to thirteen words in the Romanian original: „The correction index shall be applied only once, at the initial award of the pension.” The whole dispute turns on the phrase „the initial award of the pension”. Anyone who first drew an invalidity pension, an early retirement pension or a partial early retirement pension, and only later received an old-age pension, has two dates to which the index could be tied. The difference between them shows up in the amount received every month, because the values of the index have risen from one year to the next: 1.07 in 2014 and 2015, 1.09 in 2016, 1.14 in 2017, 1.15 in 2018, 1.20 in 2019 and 1.41 in 2020, the highest in its history.
The author of the plea, Sigrid-Elisabeta Jianu, took a partial early retirement pension in 2016, after her post had been abolished and she had found no other, and in 2020 she applied for the old-age pension. The pension house kept her 2016 index. She challenged the pension award decision before the Caras-Severin Tribunal, which referred the matter to the Constitutional Court by interlocutory judgment of 5 March 2021, in case no. 1.780/115/2020.
Her argument was one of equality: if the purpose of the index is to cover the loss caused by the longer full contribution period, then it should go to everyone whose old-age pension is calculated under the rules of Law No 263/2010, including those who reach it by way of an earlier pension. She relied on Constitutional Court Decision no. 702 of 31 October 2019, by which the same phrase had been declared constitutional only if read in favour of former recipients of an invalidity pension.
The Court answered that the situations are not the same, and this is where the whole difference between winning and losing such a case lies. In both Decision no. 702 of 31 October 2019 and Decision no. 670 of 19 October 2021, the people who succeeded had drawn their first pension under Law No 19/2000, the old law, which knew no correction index at all. For them, the first award of a pension had used up nothing, because at that date there was nothing to use up. The author of this plea, however, had drawn both pensions, the partial early retirement pension and the old-age pension, under the same Law No 263/2010, so the benefit had already been granted once. What counts is therefore the law under which the first pension was established, not the kind of pension it was.
On the same day, in Official Gazette of Romania no. 770 of 10 September 2026, the Court also publishes Decision no. 733 of 9 December 2025, delivered in the same sitting but on a different subject matter: Article 170(2) to (4) of Law No 263/2010, that is the mechanism for calculating the index, the once-only rule and the effect on the point score, taken together. The decision here concerns paragraph (3) alone and only the equality criticism raised against it. The two cases are read together, but they do not share the same subject matter and neither one summarises the other.
What it changes in practice
The decision is final and generally binding from the date of publication, 10 September 2026, under Article 147(4) of the Constitution. From that date, any court hearing a challenge in which the correction index is claimed as at the second award of a pension is bound by what the Court has established, and the ground of unconstitutionality can no longer be invoked with success.
In concrete terms, the losing party is anyone who first drew a pension from 1 January 2011 onwards, under Law No 263/2010, whether that first pension was an invalidity, early retirement or partial early retirement pension. For them, the index was already applied in the first award decision, and the conversion into an old-age pension does not create a new entitlement, it merely recalculates the amount.
The two situations in which the Court has already ruled in favour of pensioners are untouched. The first comes from Decision no. 702 of 31 October 2019: a person who had an invalidity pension under Law No 19/2000 and met the conditions for an old-age pension after 1 January 2011. The second comes from Decision no. 670 of 19 October 2021: a person whose old-age pension was established after 1 January 2011, converted from a partial early retirement pension established before that date. Both decisions upheld the pleas before them, and their effects continue to apply.
The third effect is a limit in time. Law No 263/2010 was repealed by Article 168(1)(a) of Law No 360/2023 on the public pension system and ceased to be in force on 31 August 2024, and the new calculation formula has no correction index. No new pension is established under the old law any more, so the group of people the decision concerns is no longer growing. The Court was nevertheless able to rule on a repealed provision, relying on Decision no. 766 of 15 June 2011, because the provision continues to produce effects in proceedings started earlier.
That does not mean the stakes have gone. Pensions in payment were recalculated with effect from 1 September 2024, and Article 144 of Law No 360/2023 provides that, if the recalculation gives a lower amount, the previous and more favourable one continues to be paid. Anyone who obtained a higher point score in court for the period before the recalculation would therefore raise the very sum being paid to them after 2024 as well. That is precisely why these cases did not close along with the law.
What has changed compared with the previous situation
In the letter of the law, nothing changes. The Court struck out no word and added no binding interpretation, as it had done in 2019 and in 2021. What changes is the status of the question: until 10 September 2026, a judge with such a challenge on the docket could refer the matter to the Court; from that date there is a public and reasoned answer, and a referral would have no object.
The boundary between the two earlier decisions upholding pleas also changes. Both no. 702/2019 and no. 670/2021 are framed as extensions of the benefit, and that is where the impression came from that the phrase „the initial award of the pension” might gradually be read in favour of anyone who passes through a second pension. Here the Court draws the line: the extension stops at people coming from Law No 19/2000. Anyone who was under the new law from the start is outside it.
For a first-instance judge, the answer had existed for more than four years, but by another route. By Decision no. 70/2021, published in Official Gazette of Romania no. 1256 of 31 December 2021, the High Court of Cassation and Justice ruled, with binding force, that the date on which the correction index is granted is the date on which the pension was first established under Law No 263/2010. That is exactly the rule the Constitutional Court now confirms, from the standpoint of equality of rights.
Finally, the legal framework in which the question arises has itself changed. Since 1 September 2024, pensions have been calculated under Law No 360/2023, which dropped the correction index and the differing full contribution periods, precisely because two people with the same points and the same years of work ended up with different pensions depending on the year in which they retired. The Court is therefore ruling on a problem that the new law solved by deleting the instrument rather than by clarifying it.
Advantages and disadvantages
What it improves
- The rule becomes predictable and verifiable: what counts is the law under which the first pension was established, not the type of that pension. Anyone who reads their first pension award decision knows the answer in advance.
- A source of repetitive litigation is closed off. Pension houses and tribunals now have a single answer, and identical cases no longer attract different outcomes from one county to the next.
- The Court explains the limits of its own 2019 and 2021 decisions upholding pleas, which was needed: the wording of those decisions, read on its own, suggested a wider extension than the Court had in mind.
- The reasoning draws a clear distinction between the correction index and indexation, a distinction the law never made expressly and from which many claims started out.
- The outcome was reached unanimously, so it leaves behind no dissenting opinion for other cases to build on.
What remains a problem
- The answer came after 1,740 days, that is four years and nine months from the referral to the Court, in substantive proceedings opened in 2020. For a pensioner, that is a sizeable part of the period over which the difference could have been drawn.
- Between delivery and publication, 275 days went by, and the decision becomes binding only on publication. Throughout that interval the answer existed but bound nobody.
- The consequence that the decision confirms is nowhere to be found in the law. No provision warns the person applying for a partial early retirement pension that they are thereby fixing their correction index for good.
- The Court does not mention the binding ruling of the High Court in Decision no. 70/2021, even though it answers precisely the configuration of this case and had been published four years before delivery.
- Anyone wanting to check the provision under discussion has nowhere to do it. The consolidated version of Law No 263/2010 on the legislative portal contains no reference to Law No 360/2023, which repealed it, although it carries notes for every decision upholding a plea.
Practical advice
- Look in your pension award decision for the line with the correction index and the year for which it was applied. The reference values are 1.07 for 2014 and 2015, 1.09 for 2016, 1.14 for 2017, 1.15 for 2018, 1.20 for 2019 and 1.41 for 2020.
- The question that decides a case of this kind is a single one: under which law was the first pension established. If the first pension award decision predates 1 January 2011, that is the period of Law No 19/2000, the claim has a basis in Decision no. 702 of 31 October 2019 or in Decision no. 670 of 19 October 2021. If the first decision dates from 2011 onwards, today’s decision closes the discussion.
- Ask the pension house for a copy of the first pension award decision, as well as the one currently in payment. The date on that document, and not the date of the old-age pension, fixes the index.
- Anyone with proceedings already under way should check with their lawyer whether the case rests on Decision no. 670 of 19 October 2021 and on Decision no. 70/2021 of the High Court, rather than on Decision no. 702 of 31 October 2019 alone, because those three cover different situations.
- Anyone whose pension was recalculated in 2024 would do well to compare the recalculated amount with the previous one. If the old amount stayed in payment, then a corrected point score for the past also shows up in the sum paid today, under Article 144 of Law No 360/2023.
- The full reasoning, with all 33 paragraphs, is in the Official Gazette of Romania, Part I, no. 768 of 10 September 2026, pages 5 to 8, and is reproduced below, in the section with the original text of the act.
Frequently asked questions
What is the correction index on a pension?
I took a partial early retirement pension in 2015 and an old-age pension in 2019. Can I claim the 2019 index?
Why does the law matter, if the type of pension is the same?
How much is the difference in money?
Has Law No 263/2010 not been repealed? Why does the decision still matter?
From what date does the decision apply?
I have already lost my case on this ground. Can it be reopened?
How does it relate to Decision no. 733/2025, published on the same day?
Editorial analysis
The decision does something necessary and does it clearly: it shows where the Court’s two earlier decisions upholding pleas stop. The 2019 and 2021 wordings are written as extensions of the benefit, and a reader without the case files behind them may well conclude that any second pension opens the right to a second index. It does not, and the criterion, now stated openly, is the law under which the first pension was established. It is a sound criterion, because the index remedies one single loss, the one caused by the longer full contribution period in the new law, and whoever came under that law from the start received the remedy at the right moment.
The economic stake in the case appears nowhere in the decision, although it can be calculated from the published acts. The author of the plea took her partial early retirement pension in 2016, when the index was 1.09, and her old-age pension in 2020, when the index was 1.41, the highest value the index has ever had. The ratio between the two, 1.41 divided by 1.09, is 1.294. Her claim was therefore worth an average annual point score 29.4% higher, every month, until the end of her life. That explains why 2020 produced a wave of litigation and why the provision reached the Constitutional Court and the High Court so many times. Almost a third of a pension hung on a single calendar date.
A line of thirteen Romanian words has generated at least ten rulings of the Constitutional Court and the High Court of Cassation and Justice: two decisions of the Court upholding pleas, in 2019 and 2021, three dismissals, in 2024, 2025 and 2026, the decision delivered in the same sitting on paragraphs (2) to (4), plus four interventions by the High Court, Decisions no. 71/2017 and no. 29/2018, the binding ruling no. 70/2021 and the dismissal no. 5/2024. Of these, two changed the meaning of the provision and one settled with binding force how it is to be read. The legislature had two windows of 45 days each in which to rewrite the provision in line with the decisions upholding the pleas, between 10 February and 25 March 2020 and between 6 December 2021 and 19 January 2022, and on both occasions it did nothing, so the phrase ceased to have effect by operation of law and its meaning had to be assembled from case law. Five years of repetitive litigation cost more than a one-sentence amendment.
The chronology of publication is worth looking at too, because it changes the order in which case law reaches the reader. This decision was delivered on 9 December 2025 and published on 10 September 2026, after 275 days. Decision no. 124/2026, delivered 65 days later, on 12 February 2026, was published 64 days earlier, after only 146 days. Between the same two moments, no. 545/2024 waited 247 days. Since a decision becomes binding only on publication, the two rulings on the same provision arrived in reverse order to their delivery, and a judge following the case law read the newer one before the older one. None of this affects the outcome, but it makes for hard going in an area where every month of delay translates into identical cases still being filed.
One last detail, for anyone who wants to check for themselves. The consolidated version of Law No 263/2010 on the legislative portal contains no reference to Law No 360/2023, which repealed it with effect from 1 September 2024, even though the same page carries detailed notes on every decision upholding a plea and on the annual values of the index. A reader looking for the text the Court commented on finds a law that appears to be in force. This is exactly the kind of detail that sends people to a lawyer over an entitlement that the law has granted to nobody for two years.
What should be changed
- Publication of decisions in the order in which they were delivered. The three decisions on the same provision appeared 146, 247 and 275 days after delivery, and the oldest reached the reader last. Effect: the case law on a subject is read in the order in which it was formed, and a decision already delivered no longer sits for nine months without binding anyone.
- Citation of the High Court’s binding rulings in the reasoning. Decision no. 70/2021 states, with binding force, that the date of the index is the date on which the pension was first established under Law No 263/2010, which is exactly the rule confirmed here, yet it is not mentioned. Effect: the reader of the decision learns that the answer is binding by two routes and does not start proceedings to discover the second.
- Marking the repeal in the consolidated version on the legislative portal. The page for Law No 263/2010 makes no mention of Law No 360/2023. Effect: anyone checking the provision sees at first glance that the law has not been in force since 1 September 2024 and applies only to entitlements established up to that date.
- Stating in the pension award decision the date that fixes the correction index. The pension house knows the date of the first award but does not put it next to the index applied. Effect: the pensioner sees from their own document why the index is the 2016 one and not the 2020 one, and challenges fall away without any change in the law.
- Express wording of the reference moment in any rule of the once-only type. Law No 360/2023 got rid of the correction index, but the pattern can repeat with any benefit granted a single time. Effect: a rule that states the date it refers to does not need ten rulings to become readable.
Original text of the legal act
The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.
The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania
Official Gazette of Romania no. 768 of 10 September 2026 16 pages PDF, 114 KB the act starts on page 5
Open the official PDFDownload the PDF
The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.
