In brief
- In a single decision, the Constitutional Court dismissed the pleas raised in 87 cases brought by military and police pensioners, many of them represented by the ProLex National Trade Union.
- The Court found constitutional the rule under which the military pension is updated every year with the average annual inflation rate, laid down in Article 59 of Law no. 223/2015 in the wording given by Emergency Ordinance no. 59/2017. The wording in force is the one given by Government Emergency Ordinance no. 114/2018, from 29 December 2018: pensions are indexed automatically from 1 January, and in 2025 and 2026 indexation was suspended by law.
- The clause that stopped any decrease in the 2017 wording, under which the amount in payment was kept, was replaced in 2018. The wording in force provides that pensions are not indexed if the average annual inflation rate is negative.
Published: Official Gazette of Romania (Monitorul Oficial) no. 699 of 24 August 2026
Delivered: 26 March 2026
Correction, 16 November 2026
The article presented the 2017 wording of Article 59 of Law no. 223/2015, with the annual update and the clause that kept the amount in payment, as the wording in force, and the title stated that the decision had closed 87 cases. The Court dismissed the pleas of unconstitutionality raised in those cases; the proceedings continue before the courts hearing them.
The 2017 wording was replaced from 29 December 2018 by Article 84 point 1 of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 114/2018: military pensions in payment on 31 December of the previous year are indexed automatically from 1 January, and if the average annual inflation rate is negative, they are not indexed. Military pensions were not indexed in 2025 (Article XVI paragraph (8) of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 156/2024) and are not indexed in 2026 (Article XXX paragraph (8) of Law no. 141/2025).
The point on paragraph 32 of the decision has been removed from the list of errors, because that paragraph states expressly that Article 59 is examined in the wording given to it „by Article VII point 2” of Emergency Ordinance no. 59/2017. The text below has been corrected accordingly.
The pleas raised in eighty-seven cases from all over the country, dismissed by a single decision: the military and police pensioners who contested the way their pension is updated have lost again at the Constitutional Court. By Decision no. 283 of 26 March 2026, published in Official Gazette of Romania no. 699 of 24 August 2026, the Court dismissed as unfounded the pleas raised in proceedings pending before the Dolj Tribunal, the Harghita Tribunal, the Vrancea Tribunal, the Craiova Court of Appeal and several Bucharest courts. This is the second wide-ranging decision on the same subject to be published in less than a week, after the one in which the Court confirmed the cap that stops the net military pension at the average of net military pay.
What was challenged this time is broader. Not a single article, but Government Emergency Ordinance no. 59/2017 as a whole, published in Official Gazette of Romania no. 648 of 7 August 2017, plus Article VII of it, Article 84 of Emergency Ordinance no. 114/2018 and Article 59 of Law no. 223/2015 on military state pensions, in the wording given by Article VII point 2 of the 2017 ordinance.
Article VII of the 2017 ordinance is the one that rewrote three things at once. It brought into the law the definitions of „net monthly military pay” and „net pension”, it changed Article 59, moving from an update tied to the pay of serving personnel to an update with the average annual inflation rate, and it changed Article 60, introducing the cap that stops the net pension at the average of the net military pay in the calculation base.
What it changes in practice
The first effect concerns the updating rule. The Court found constitutional Article 59 of Law no. 223/2015 as written in 2017: the amount of military state pensions is updated automatically, every year, with the average annual inflation rate, a final indicator known on 1 January of the year in which the update is made and communicated by the National Institute of Statistics. That wording was replaced from 29 December 2018 by Article 84 point 1 of Emergency Ordinance no. 114/2018, which is also among the provisions found constitutional: pensions in payment on 31 December of the previous year are indexed automatically, from 1 January, with the latest average annual inflation rate. By way of derogation, military pensions were not indexed in 2025 (Article XVI paragraph (8) of Government Emergency Ordinance no. 156/2024) and are not indexed in 2026 (Article XXX paragraph (8) of Law no. 141/2025).
The second effect concerns the protective clause. The 2017 wording provided that, if the update produces a smaller amount, the pension already in payment is maintained. The wording in force, Article 59 paragraph (2), provides that pensions are not indexed if the average annual inflation rate is negative, so the amount stays the one in payment.
The third effect concerns the definitions introduced in 2017. The law keeps „net monthly military pay or salary”, defined as gross pay minus the individual contribution to the state budget, the individual contribution to the health insurance budget and income tax, and „net pension”, defined as the military pension established as a gross amount minus income tax. They are the basis on which the cap is calculated.
The fourth effect has to do with successive indexations. Article 60, in the wording given by Article 84 of Emergency Ordinance no. 114/2018, provides that, when indexation pushes the net pension above the average net military pay, the resulting amount is granted, but without exceeding the sum obtained by applying the average annual inflation rate to that average. Where indexations follow one another, the limit is calculated cumulatively, by adding the inflation effect of the earlier operations. The Court did not touch this mechanism.
The fifth effect is procedural and shows up in the courtrooms straight away. The decision is final and generally binding, so the 87 cases can be resumed and the courts can no longer set aside the contested provisions. Among those who raised the pleas is the ProLex National Trade Union, which acted on behalf of several of its members. The argument about the contribution for the supplementary pension returned in September 2026, when the Court explained why the cap can erase a supplement paid for two decades.
What has changed compared with the previous situation
The decision does not amend the law, and the wording of Article 59 it reproduces had already been replaced on 29 December 2018. What changes is the certainty: until this decision was published, dozens of cases were on hold, with the same open question about whether the 2017 ordinance was constitutional.
The second change is that the argument about how the ordinance was adopted is now closed. Those who raised the pleas had relied on Article 115 paragraphs (4) and (6) of the Constitution, on the conditions under which the Government may issue emergency ordinances, on Article 79 paragraph (1), on the opinion of the Legislative Council, and on Article 61 paragraph (1), on the role of Parliament. The Court referred to Decision no. 723 of 12 December 2023, published in Official Gazette of Romania no. 349 of 15 April 2024, and found that no new elements had arisen.
The third change concerns the European arguments. Through Article 20 paragraph (1) of the Constitution, the pleas had also invoked Article 14 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, on the prohibition of discrimination, and Article 1 of the First Additional Protocol, on the protection of property. On this ground too the Court found no reason to reconsider its case-law.
What does not change is the right to a military state pension. The decision concerns the way the pension is updated and capped, not the existence of the pension or the conditions under which it is granted. Not only the updating but also the starting value of the correction index reached the Court: the index differs from one year of retirement to another and is not updated afterwards.
Advantages and disadvantages
What it improves
- It unblocks 87 cases that had been stayed in courts across the country, some of them since 2020.
- It confirms that annual indexation is carried out automatically, so the pensioner does not have to file any application, in the years in which the law does not suspend it.
- It confirms the rule under which the pension does not go down through indexation: when the inflation rate is negative, pensions are not indexed and stay at the amount in payment.
- It brings predictability to the sectoral pension houses, which were applying the rules under the risk of a retroactive change.
What remains a problem
- Indexation stays tied to inflation rather than to the pay of serving personnel, so the gap compared with those still in service can widen over time.
- The cap introduced in 2017 stays, and for pensioners with long service it can noticeably cut the result of the basic formula.
- The Court did not re-examine on the merits the complaints about how the ordinance was adopted, but referred to a 2023 decision, which leaves the discussion without any fresh reasoning.
- Joining 87 cases in a single decision means that the particular circumstances of each set of proceedings could not be discussed separately.
Practical advice
- If you have proceedings pending on this subject, talk to your lawyer before the next hearing. The court can no longer set aside the contested provisions, so the arguments have to move to other ground, if there is any left.
- Check on your January pension slip whether indexation was applied. It is carried out automatically, but it is worth confirming. In 2025 and 2026 indexation was suspended by law, so the absence of an increase in those years is not an error by the sectoral pension house.
- Do not confuse indexation with recalculation. Indexation, called updating in the 2017 wording, is the annual operation with the inflation rate, while recalculation means redoing the calculation on the basis of other elements in the pension file.
- If your pension did not go up at all in a given year, check first whether the law suspended indexation that year, as happened in 2025 and 2026, and then the average annual inflation rate communicated by the National Institute of Statistics. Article 59 paragraph (2) provides that, if the rate is negative, pensions are not indexed.
- If you are a member of a trade union that acted on your behalf, ask it for a written view on what the decision means for your own file. The ProLex National Trade Union is among those whose pleas were dismissed.
- Bear in mind that the decision does not reopen expired time limits. If you want to challenge a pension decision, the ordinary time limits in Law no. 223/2015 apply.
Frequently asked questions
What did the Constitutional Court decide, in short?
How is the military state pension indexed?
Can the pension go down as a result of indexation?
What does net pension mean, as the law defines it?
In how many cases were the pleas dismissed?
What happens now to the stayed proceedings?
Errors and inconsistencies in the published text
- Paragraph 8: seven interlocutory rulings for eight case files. The text says „prin încheierile nr. 574, nr. 577, nr. 580, nr. 573, nr. 575, nr. 578, nr. 579 din 18 mai 2023, pronunțate în dosarele nr. 249/96/2023, nr. 256/96/2023, nr. 277/96/2023, nr. 331/96/2023, nr. 247/96/2023, nr. 254/96/2023, nr. 286/96/2023 și nr. 330/96/2023”. Seven ruling numbers are listed against eight case files of the Harghita Tribunal, although the rest of the paragraph treats each file as having a ruling of its own. One number is missing from the series, most probably no. 576, the only one absent from the range 573 to 580.
- Case file no. 27.181/3/2023 is attributed to the Alba Tribunal. The number appears three times in the decision, in paragraphs 3 and 22 and in the operative part, each time linked to the Alba Tribunal, First Civil Division. In the same decision, the other 32 files bearing the court code „/3/” all belong to the Bucharest Tribunal, Eighth Division for labour disputes and social insurance. The court code and the name of the court cannot both be right: either the file number belongs to the Bucharest Tribunal, or the Alba file carries a different code.
- Paragraph 11: a judgment with no day. The text cites „Sentința civilă nr. 3.651 din iunie 2023, pronunțată în Dosarul nr. 5.454/3/2023*”, civil judgment no. 3.651 of June 2023, while all the other 31 referral documents in the same paragraph carry a full date, with day, month and year. The date is what makes it possible to find the judgment in the court’s own records.
- Paragraph 24: a set of rules from 2024 invoked against an ordinance from 2017. Among the texts said to have been breached when Emergency Ordinance no. 59/2017 was adopted, published on 7 August 2017, is Article 19 point IV letter b) of the Rules on the organisation and functioning of the Legislative Council, approved by Decision of the Standing Bureaus no. 4/2024, published in Official Gazette of Romania no. 970 of 26 September 2024. Rules that entered into force seven years after the ordinance was adopted cannot have been breached by the procedure of that adoption. In the same place the name is printed „Birourilor permanente ale Cameri Deputaților”, instead of „Camerei Deputaților”.
Editorial analysis
The decision solves a real administrative problem and solves it efficiently: 87 files coming from 17 courts, some of them opened in 2020, raised the same question, and joining them into a single file, the earliest registered one, avoids 87 identical decisions. On that count the technique used by the Court is sound and would be worth using more often in mass litigation.
The difficulty is one of proportion. Of the seven pages published in the Official Gazette of Romania, the reasoning proper takes up two paragraphs, 34 and 35, which say that the provisions have already been examined in Decision no. 723 of 12 December 2023 and that no new elements have arisen. The rest is enumeration: the same 87 file numbers appear three times, in paragraphs 3 and 5 and in the operative part. A pensioner looking for the reason why he lost has to find Official Gazette of Romania no. 349 of 15 April 2024 and read paragraphs 109 to 117 and 128 to 130 there, to which the Court merely refers. It is no accident that the transcription slips noted above have crept into precisely these repeated lists.
The second thing that catches the eye is the relationship between the opinions of the courts and the answer they received. In 27 of the 87 files, the court that referred the matter took the view itself that the plea was well founded, mainly because the opinion of the Legislative Council was sought after the ordinance had been adopted rather than before, and without observing the 24 hour deadline in Article 4 paragraph (3) of Law no. 73/1993. Among them are the Dolj Tribunal, the Harghita Tribunal with all ten of its files, the Mureș Tribunal with six and the Covasna Tribunal with three. That argument, adopted by almost a third of the referring courts, gets not a single line of its own in the decision. In another 14 files the court’s opinion is missing altogether: in six because it was never given, contrary to Article 29 paragraph (4) of Law no. 47/1992, and in eight because the Bucharest Tribunal took the view that giving it would amount to prejudging the case. The Court notes the situation and moves on.
That leaves the calendar. The oldest file starts from an interlocutory ruling of 12 January 2021, the decision is delivered on 26 March 2026 and published on 24 August 2026. Five years and two months from referral to solution, plus five months between delivery and publication, a time in which the 87 sets of proceedings stayed suspended, because the effects of the decision begin on publication.
What should be changed
- Reasoning by reference should come with the text, not only with the address. Where the Court disposes of a case by pointing to paragraphs 109 to 117 and 128 to 130 of Decision no. 723/2023, those paragraphs ought to be reproduced in an annex to the new decision. Anyone reading Official Gazette of Romania no. 699 would then find the reason in the same issue, without hunting for Official Gazette of Romania no. 349 of 2024.
- Complaints that the referring courts adopted as their own should receive an express answer. Here, the question of the Legislative Council’s opinion being sought after adoption was held to be well founded by the courts in 27 files. A few lines of reasoning on that particular point would close the discussion better than a blanket reference to earlier case law.
- The lists of files should be published as an annexed table, not three times in running text. A table giving the court, the number of the file on the merits, the referral document and the number of the file at the Court would remove exactly the kind of error found in paragraph 8 and would allow the match between rulings and files to be checked automatically.
- A statutory deadline for publishing the decisions of the Court. Five months passed between delivery and publication, in which nothing could be resumed before the courts. A deadline of the order of 30 days, as for other categories of act, would shorten the suspension of the proceedings by several months.
- Clarification of the status of the court’s opinion. Law no. 47/1992 requires the court to state its opinion but does not say what happens if it does not, and the Bucharest Tribunal refuses to do so with reasons, invoking the risk of prejudging the case. A text settling whether the opinion is mandatory or optional would remove the 14 files out of 87 in which it is missing.
- Annual publication of the rate applied. Indexation is carried out automatically, from 1 January, with the latest average annual inflation rate communicated by the National Institute of Statistics, but the pensioner has nowhere to check which rate was actually applied to him. The sectoral pension houses could publish in January the rate used and the resulting coefficient, and the pension slip could show the amount before and after indexation.
Original text of the legal act
The text below is reproduced in Romanian, the official form of publication.
The full text, as published in the Official Gazette of Romania
Official Gazette of Romania no. 699 of 24 August 2026 32 pages PDF, 202 KB the act starts on page 2
Open the official PDFDownload the PDF
The viewer is not shown on small screens. Use the buttons above to open or download the file.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult a licensed attorney or tax advisor.
